I do agree with you there, I will take it even a step further - the orc, dwarf, and pirate lady are straight up gross. Cait is 'OK' but I wouldn't consider her attractive. It's really confusing how we ended up with only 2 decent LIs and 3-4 duds.idk if it fell off but the orc and the dwarf are too weird for me, other characters are very attractive tho
Unfortunately I think there is a modern trend of taking the rainbow approach - "let's throw something for everyone in!" I hate that trend lol. It's compounded in a lot of games nowadays by the equally shitty trend of forcing the player to advance LIs they aren't interested in, to advance the story. (It used to be you just had to pick one LI and pursue them and if you wanted to pursue another one that would be a whole separate playthrough with different choices made. But now everyone is lazy and just wants to clear all the content in a single run so here we are.)
My 5 star review stands though, because Lyriel is hot as fuck.