Well, I think the original post was a constructive one, he did not say anything like "L&P's use of light sucks" and that was it, he developed his opinion and hey, I believe it deserves to be respected. In fact, he stated several times that he was doing a great job and that he liked the renders very much.
Now look at the author's reply, full of irony:
- "Is it comprehensible now? Is there more? Maybe the dispersion of the window of the car outside is physically wrong or maybe the density of air relative to the sunny time zone has to cause other light arrays in the room?"
- "Do you guys really have nothing better to do then trying forcefully to find any bullshit to bitch about and put my work down? Since it's not the first time! But yeah, you're actually a "big fan" and you actually don't wanna criticize anything, right?"
If your work is so perfect, don't answer random users about things like that, it seems like the author is being attacked or something. I mean come on, you don't have to answer to a thing like this because there will always be someone who won't like some part of your game... we can make 1000000 comments about the story and get no reply, but make one about how bad the light is and get a long answer... that fact already tells you something.
I don't understand why you keep defending him in everything like no possible criticism is valid! It seems that if you don't like something you become a hater... and this could be extended to all devs.