The way that Our Fate does it is more realistic. You bang your girlfriend while starting to develop feelings for someone else.
Once you feel that your feelings for the new girl is too much you cheat or break it up. etc. etc.
TLDR: The premise of a marriage makes it unnecessary to blue ball the player to this extreme. One sex scene somewhere in the game could have given player a sex scene without changing the overall dynamic of the game. The premise of the game is an adult game after all? This frustrates a lot of people playing the game.
The only thing that i don't like in this game is the point system and how the different routes/paths are separated.
First of all how the lesbian route is compatible with "good wife"? It doesn't make sense. And what is the reward/ending of the "good wife" path? To have sex with her hasband after 5 years ? This is ridiculus.
If you want to seperate the point system to 2 basic categories such us "good wife" and "filthy" at least make the "good wife" compatible with Dylan and Ellie as well and you can rename it to "faithfull to the family". Or make at least Dylan and Ellie paths independable to filthy points. For example why Sophia have to fuck the gym boy (to get some filthy points) to be able to progress the story with Dylan?
Ok, folks, I have a shocking suggestion. Instead of companing about how the game sucks, how much you disappointed and other similat things...let's write all this to dev in a coherent and adequate manner. That is what I did two days ago, when I realized that I had a number of questions that I wanted to get answers to.As you say here:
And what is the reward/ending of the "good wife" path? To have sex with her hasband after 5 years ? This is ridiculus.
That's my complain, the whole scenario is unrealistic. There is plenty of slow burn games I enjoy. Our Fate is one of them. Melody is another. But the scenario and premise is more realistic. Love it or hate it, but that's what makes incest a "good" tool for slow burn adult games. The Taboo puts the brakes on the sex side of such a relationship, where none exits for a married couple.
From a small correspondence with the author and after reading his Patreon page I've learned that (according to him) that "The story is already planned out (and also already written!!!) for about 30 playable days" and he will stick to his plan. So, if we really want to make him change his mind, we need good arguments.