Yes, there could have been her mind game if L&P had followed its original plan and alternately told the story from Sophias and then again from Liam's point of view. Now Liam is just a projection surface for the main character Sophia. That is exactly why I think it is so difficult to tell a swinger event in such a short time frame. This erotic game that you propose cannot work if the 4 people only have a maximum of 3 evenings available maybe.Thank you for your reply to my question. The upcoming Andy and Cathy event has stirred my imagination, and what I propose is just a notion of whimsy. What if there was chemistry in the past between Liam and Cathy as well as with Andy and Sophia? Whether the chemistry was realized in either case 20 years ago may play into this idea.
What if old feelings quietly emerge between Sophia and Andy, and likewise between Liam and Cathy? To continue the thought, what if these feelings Sophia has grows independently of Liam's feelings for Cathy? There could be a short string of events in which Sophia's fidelity is tested by temptation for Andy, while at the same time Liam's commitment to Sophia is tested with Cathy. This could raise the question as to who is more loyal. Would Sophia secretly succumb to her lust? Would Liam resist the willing arms of Cathy's embrace as a final fling before her wedding? Would both give into their lust, and in independent scenarios consummate their latent desires? It would be even more entertaining if Andy and Cathy were in collusion to test the long marriage of their long-time friends. I would personally enjoy the dramatic tension leading up to such an event, as well as how the secret liaison(s) would resolve.
I agree the swinger event can only work as a short circuit event in my opinion. The starting point would be Laim's obvious interest in Cathy for Sophia, which is likely to be reciprocated. Perhaps in an unobserved moment, Cathy is acting quite aggressively. Sophia sees it. On both the Good Wife and Filthy routes, Sophia is injured (and also aroused). And wants to catch up and starts the game with Andrew. In the meantime, Liam has rejected Cathy and is returning to his wife. And now, for his part, observes Sophia and Andrew in action. He too feels hurt now and continues with Cathy. They both end up having sex. They can then talk about it on the Good-Wife Route and start a new chapter in their relationship. On the Filthy route, both will pretend they don't know what the other has done.
I am here because of such mind games! That makes the difference to other games. And that's why all the side stories are important to me. To have fun.