- Sep 28, 2018
- 4,279
- 22,876
A simpler story is always easier than a more complex one. This game, and others, have a lot of overlap in routes and characters. You don't need multiple routes or characters that do the same thing or serve the same purpose. Instead, you can have roughly the same amount of content, just add the excess Characters/routes to more solidified and purposeful ones. Characters should have depth and having depth means they can serve multiple different roles, if needed.
Do we really need 2 side-jobs? No. Instead of having 2 different routes, just do one side-job and double it's content. The side-jobs are especially wasteful as it's obvious L&P made them to cover the young/old fetishes. Idea: Sophia's own father needs help, maybe she takes Dylan or Ellie to help her care for him. That alone would serve practically the same purpose as the old man side job. She can teach her own kids sex ed. She doesn't need to be manipulated by a few horny 12yr old's. Adding 1 character and eliminating 5. Yet maintaining roughly the same content.
Do we really need multiple blackmail routes? No. Condense them into one or two routes and make them more distinct. Dylan doesn't need to go to boarding school. Not only is it not needed, it stalls Dylan's route. Pick 1 school blackmailer, give them different blackmail material, and pick one out of school blackmailer.
Do we really need all the sets of friends? No. As before, combine the roles into a couple sets of friends instead of half a dozen. Sofia/Ellie and Dylan all have multiple friends.
Do we really need the random side-characters like the college kids or whoever else? No. Same as above, pick the best ones or even better give their content to the mains. I'd much rather have a Dylan/Sam/Sofia/Patricia museum tour than the college kids stuff.
My magic wand character eliminator: (going off the character sheet in the OP)
Carl - His role goes to nobody as he is irrelevant.
Nat - Yes, I did it. Replace her role with Julia.
Janitor dude - His shower goes to Mr. Bennett, who is still a blackmailer.
Aiden + his friends - Their role is taken by Bennett.
Ellie's friends besides Christine - Their roles are taken by Julia.
College guys - Their roles go to Dylan and Sam.
The Fitness instructors + fitness guys - Their roles are filled by Ellie + Patricia Dylan and Sam
Logan - Ellie doesn't need a BF, she's got her momma. If she has to, Sam can fill this role.
Side job # 1 - See above
Side job #2 - See above
Park hobo's and thugs - All gone, by. Replace their screen time with a new event for a main character.
And that's not even half of them, the list is out of date.
Do we really need 2 side-jobs? No. Instead of having 2 different routes, just do one side-job and double it's content. The side-jobs are especially wasteful as it's obvious L&P made them to cover the young/old fetishes. Idea: Sophia's own father needs help, maybe she takes Dylan or Ellie to help her care for him. That alone would serve practically the same purpose as the old man side job. She can teach her own kids sex ed. She doesn't need to be manipulated by a few horny 12yr old's. Adding 1 character and eliminating 5. Yet maintaining roughly the same content.
Do we really need multiple blackmail routes? No. Condense them into one or two routes and make them more distinct. Dylan doesn't need to go to boarding school. Not only is it not needed, it stalls Dylan's route. Pick 1 school blackmailer, give them different blackmail material, and pick one out of school blackmailer.
Do we really need all the sets of friends? No. As before, combine the roles into a couple sets of friends instead of half a dozen. Sofia/Ellie and Dylan all have multiple friends.
Do we really need the random side-characters like the college kids or whoever else? No. Same as above, pick the best ones or even better give their content to the mains. I'd much rather have a Dylan/Sam/Sofia/Patricia museum tour than the college kids stuff.
My magic wand character eliminator: (going off the character sheet in the OP)
Carl - His role goes to nobody as he is irrelevant.
Nat - Yes, I did it. Replace her role with Julia.
Janitor dude - His shower goes to Mr. Bennett, who is still a blackmailer.
Aiden + his friends - Their role is taken by Bennett.
Ellie's friends besides Christine - Their roles are taken by Julia.
College guys - Their roles go to Dylan and Sam.
The Fitness instructors + fitness guys - Their roles are filled by Ellie + Patricia Dylan and Sam
Logan - Ellie doesn't need a BF, she's got her momma. If she has to, Sam can fill this role.
Side job # 1 - See above
Side job #2 - See above
Park hobo's and thugs - All gone, by. Replace their screen time with a new event for a main character.
And that's not even half of them, the list is out of date.