making a cuck out of dylan makes no sense to me. sports guy, manipulative, sex driven, bodypositive always looking for body contact.
sam is such a beta compared to him. soft talk, music and romance, insecure, mommy's boy.
Look a little more in depth into the story. The cuck path for Dylan is just a different manifestation of his shyness, and despite all the testosterone flowing around, he hasn't had a good male role model to show him how to direct it. Liam thinks he might even be gay, for all the attention Liam shows Dylan. So Dylan is, for good reasons, confused and unsure of himself.
If he had the confidence and the BDE, he wouldn't
need to be manipulative. He could just go out and get what he wants. He wouldn't need to couch things in a fashion show, or breakfast in bed, just to see things like Sophia in skimpy clothing (which she still thinks is weird BTW). The whole point of Sophia trying to set him up with a girlfriend (at this stage either Emma or Marie), is to give him someone his own age that he can experiment with, so he can get the confidence.
So the cuck path as an option just adds a little more depth to his character, since this game is more about story and a slow burn, as opposed to getting to the sex scenes as quickly as possible, for people that just want the son to fuck the mother. It's the flaws in Dylan's character that make him more like a real person, leading to character development and actual story