So, I mentioned this briefly in a previous comment but I wanted to go a bit deeper into the criticism. Let me just say that by all means, do what you will with the story and I'll still enjoy this game: it's quickly becoming one of my favorites and has the potential to be an amazing game. Try not to look at this as a complaint, but rather, just some honest feedback. This is just a personal opinion and some constructive criticism, nothing more.
Anyway, here it goes:
Liam cheating on Sophia is detrimental to the game. Not just the story itself, but the kink aspect, the thrill of Sophia being naughty, and the overall "hotness" of the (future) sexual content.
First of all, it's blatantly obvious and the fact that Sophia hasn't connected the dots yet is mind boggling. Seeing the girl in the clothing store, then later in the office, Liam being there and then quickly leaving. Coming home later and later every night. Lack of interest in the bedroom, etc. She should've already put two and two together, and I'm not saying this as just an outside observer with a broader lens, but I'm speaking as if I were in Sophia's shoes.
Now, the biggest problem I have with the fact that Liam is cheating is, well... it cheapens the thrill, nearly ruins it, frankly. Being filthy as Sophia is meaningless. It's like, why would Liam care? He's already banging some hot young chick and seems to have little interest in Sophia, sexually. So by cheating on him, you're more or less just evening things out. Frankly, the two of you may as well be in an open relationship at this point. Simply put, with the way the story is going, being filthy as Sophia will come with zero aspect of betrayal, taboo, and far less excitement. She may as well just be a whore, not a housewife going back on her vows. It sucks, really. It's going to bug me for a while. To be frank, the game might as well just be about her being single, as that would be equally as exciting. There was a huge opportunity missed here, as there is nothing hotter than the idea of a very hot mom with 2 grown kids and a loyal husband betraying everything dear to her, risking it all to embrace her filthy, kinky side.
But meh, this is just my opinion and I'm sure there's some people who are into the whole "naive, gullible whore of a housewife fucking all the neighborhood teens while being unknowingly cucked even though it's right in her face" shtick, but that's just not really up my alley. I'd of much preferred the "Perfect woman with a very loving, loyal, and attached husband and two sweet kids starts to come out of her prudish shell, after moving to a new town, tired of living through the same old boring commitment with her husband and slowly discovers her filthy side and submits to temptation."
I also think this could've been perfectly doable, considering there are multiple paths. For instance, perhaps Liam could've been cheating on her in the "Good wife" path, but the opposite of that in the "Filthy path" (you cheating on him, him being faithful vs him cheating on you, you being faithful). Ah well, I'll get over it. Looking forward to future updates! (maybe one day I can write my own story for one of these games, and then I can explore all these wishes & expectations of mine! If you're a game dev, and you're interested, I've been writing articles and stories for years and I'm considering taking on my own little project, here. I just don't know how to create games, hmph. HMU!)