- Aug 15, 2019
- 450
- 1,120
- Thread starter CobraSGT
- Start date
Still, I wish people would try to branch out. I've played a few games set in Russia, and even the few subtle variations on daily life were really intriguing. There's erotic scenarios in other countries that you would rarely see in the USA.
Also, the problem of sameness isn't necessarily that we're confined to America-America is a huge and varied place, which helps feed its massive cultural complex. The problem is that we're largely stuck in two areas of American life: life in an upper-middle class suburban family, or the life of an upper-middle class college student. I'd daresay that accounts for 80%+ of the games on here, and I think it's noteworthy that some of the highest rated games like City of Broken Dreamers or Long Live the Princess are those that break out of that area somewhat.
Problem is, those sterile suburbs or cookie-cutter families are not *inherently interesting*. There are interesting stories to be told there, but not with the quality of writing in your average porn game. Hence, we have 500 games about fucking your neighbors, classmates, or family that are so alike as to be interchangeable.
After the colossal disappointment that was Subverse, I think it'll be a long time until the western porn game market reaches the level of Japan or Korea. I mean, it's nuts how different it is there-in those countries you'll have pornographic stories that tell towering romances, epic fantasy tales, or gritty real life crime stories. They'll get adapted into full shows (usually not as smutty, of course), movies, or even major franchises that make gobs of cash over decades. And in the west? We have 10,000 ways to fuck your mom. But only if she looks like she's an extra from an early 90's saturday morning kid's show like Reboot.
I don't think it's necessarily true that as many are set in America as claimed. I'd say it's true that they're overwhelmingly set in The West but many have blatant character slang and general lexicon that isn't American. It may seem so due to being mostly white and such but then you see nothing but uncircumcised dicks, people playing football (soccer) rather than American Football, calling people "tossers" and other very non-American things.
I'd actually propose that most writers seem to be British or from a country colonized by them in the not-so-distant past. So, definitely Western but not necessarily American. I can't think of many popular devs that come across to me as blatantly or obviously American.
All that said, I do get and agree with your sentiments. Games set in other, Non-Western locales would be welcome.
Whatever country they're meant to be set in, it might as well be the same flavorless suburb in the Central Valley of California that all the sitcoms exported from America seem to be set in. If you don't make use of a location's uniqueness, it's pretty much irrelevant, IMO.
Hell, I don't even necessarily need a game set in Turkey to be interesting. Just get *out* of the suburb! Leave your siblings alone-there's much cooler people to fuck! Set it on a ship in the doldrums at sea! Set it deep in the countryside! Set it in an FOB in a country at war!
Or maybe it's just that the audience has bad taste. After all, what does my whining and bleating matter if a new developer sees Summertime Saga making a truly *hilarious* amount of money and wants to try and replicate that for themselves?
- Feb 14, 2018
- 1,422
- 4,890
"rarely"? You're more versed than I am so I'll take that at face value.
I recently read through a portion of the script, I don't actually remember which scene but must have been school/teaching related, and the dialogue was chopped up like "If day??_rejected_aiden = False Then" and then immediately followed by "If day??_rejected_aiden_2nd_task = False Then" followed by "If day??_rejected_aiden_3d_task = False then" - I don't remember the actual variable names, but the entire scene had that structure, and many of the blocks within the scene had that same structure, so he was testing for individual lines of dialogue within the scene.
I may have stumbled upon a particularly awkward section though, and as you say this may be more the exception rather than the rule.
- Feb 14, 2018
- 1,422
- 4,890
I think at least some of it has to do with the availability of assets, the types of interiors and exteriors of houses, or housing, I should say, especially. But you're right, there's a lot "writing what you know" going on, and American television and movies provide enough reference material to give one the impression that they do actually know.
Yeah, TBH, I was feeling the same way. It's not that they're trying to hint at a non-American location by throwing in uncircumcised cocks and people saying weird British slang, it's that you have an Italian or French or Russian developer who doesn't know American men are universally circumcised and watched British TV along with American TV their whole life and doesn't know where the two clash. And these games are all made with the same generic free model-set, so that's why they are all set in the same cookie-cutter suburbia, have the same restaurant and school locations, and even use the same faces.
A few of these games are near something you'd consider acceptable for even an Indie game...but most are solidly hobbyist tier. Right now, I'd say the Last Sovereign is the only game I've ever recommended to someone outside of this forum of fellow masturbation enthusiasts. It has a deep, engaging, and beautiful story and is one of the few RPGM games that makes the combat not feel like a complete waste of my time. I told a friend of mine who is largely asexual but loves RPGs, and he dumped over 100 hours in it.
- Oct 20, 2019
- 2,003
- 9,488
Scandal, a game inspired by this one, takes place in Milan, Italy. I haven't played it.
Summer's End - Hong Kong 1986 has a great reputation, the art is top class and it seems to be made by professionals. I have not played it yet, it seems a vanilla game about a lesbian romance, which put great emphasis in the cultural context. It's 2D.
- Jul 20, 2019
- 9,005
- 17,576
I do occasionally wonder if the reason Dylan doesn't play American football, and that we haven't seen Ellie cheerleading for it, is actually the complete lack of assets for it. I've looked, and the complete lack of decent sports fields really is astounding.
- Feb 20, 2020
- 1,137
- 1,204
Well, complete lack of assets is surely relative, yes? If you were willing to pay, almost anything you can imagine has been textured, mapped onto a skeleton, and even been given movement assets. It's not like it costs a ton to buy these assets, either.
- Jun 12, 2018
- 372
- 2,095
- Oct 20, 2019
- 2,003
- 9,488
It could be that or the fact tha Dylan is a little skinny boy who would be murdered by american high school football players.
It doesn't really matter what sport he plays-it's not like actually playing the sport plays a role in the story. It could be a chess club meeting, it's just a story frame location.
- Jul 20, 2019
- 9,005
- 17,576
Have you had a look at the Daz store for sports field assets? It's either basketball or soccer.
- May 17, 2021
- 33
- 37
- Oct 20, 2019
- 2,003
- 9,488
No, I don't know anything about assets, but even if those would have existed, I think american football is not the sport proper for Dylan.
...haha, you know, while I still maintain the exact sport doesn't matter, you're absolutely right. Thinking on it, only games like Being a Dik where they have an actual artist to render things have games other than basketball or soccer.
Put lacrosse assets on the store and watch every new boy out to fuck his mom be a star lacrosse player lol. Or do a really weird game, like curling. Oh! Caber tossing!