Thanks for sharing!
It feels like
View attachment 1699134
Can we use the lifelines?
Clearly B and D are pure trolling.
A, C, E are plausible, especially A, which could explain why he stranded Ellie the night before. But she won't just be pouting on the swing, I guess..
I'm more for E because otherwise he'd give it away.
But it is NOT my final answer!
After seeing this I couldn't help but to weigh in on this splendid controversy. There have already been several well thought-out answers given. I, for one, buy into option 'C' for the following reasons:
First quoting one of my previous posts. "What we do know about Ellie is what L&P told us in her introduction, "Though she is that popular and desired she isn't stuck up at all and is even a little shy. Though outwardly she is often acts bitchy and extremely cool." To me, this resonates of someone who wears a mask and has not developed a strong self-image foundation. This implies that she is swayed rather easily by others who show some force of will, or personal conviction.
Ellie's actions moving through the story so far reinforces this impression. Ellie hooks up with a tattooed man (Logan), and soon is sporting tattoos of her own. Ellie encounters a lesbian (Julia) and in spite of having no experience being attracted to women in the past becomes Julia's girlfriend. Note that this happens even if the player makes every decision to the contrary. Finally, even after telling Christine that she is smoking due to peer pressure, yields to peer pressure herself and takes a puff."
If Logan asked for nude pics he should be able to convince her as (it appears) he did for her getting tattoos.
During date night with Sophia at the night club I believe it was Tyler that inferred that if Logan was not such a "loose cannon" he would go much farther with his modelling ambitions. Braydon also mentioned at the spa that Logan was on the 6-year-plan at college. Given this, the Logan personality could very well just 'not show' for the beach event with Ellie. It is not a far reach for this same personality to share these nude pictures, and get caught the next day when Ellie unexpectedly stops by (asking why he was not at the beach party). I also agree with a previous post which mentioned that Ellie seemed pretty unhappy on the swing with the phone in her hand.
Just one man's perspective, Jack.