The point is that a game can't be everything. It is important to have a focus. That doesn't mean forgetting everything around it, just not losing sight of the focus either. If we're being honest, we have to say that L&P has simply opened up far too many side stories that he will never be able to tell to a degree where they really make sense. If everything is revisited at all, it will come across as an incoherent rehashing from as many as possible kinks and therefore make little sense. Just take the nursing home story as an example. To simply include something like this in AWAM provides no depth, but only distracts. If L&P would use more time here by removing other side stories, while at the same time increasing the connection to the main story, e.g. by having Ellie support Sopia as punishment (for something bad she may have done, eg. because she game Dylan viagra), then it would become a connected story that is more than just a useless kink run off. The same is true for lesbian LI. Here it would be better not to have so many girls, but one or max two, that Sophia then but really means something. Ultimately, too much is simply not an improvement but a deterioration.
Also, For the people who really dislike Incest, I really wonder if AWAM should be the right thing for them, because in the end it would only degrades the quality of the game. Even the fact that L&P includes a path in which Dylan is sent away, I think is a stupid idea. Who really does not like Incest, It's not only Dylan, but also Ellie, whose story would have to move into the background. I think that would be a really big mistake. Sophia would then just be there to emotionlessly fuck through as many kinks as possible.