I'm talking specifically about the rationale that the Twist was removed (hence L&P comprimising his story) because it upset Dylan supporters, and that they would leave. And that even if Dylan supporters did leave, it wouldn't really significantly effect L&P's total numbers.
Using some actual numbers (I don't recall the numbers just after the decision to remove the Twist - I'm using the ones from the last poll), but Dylan had 400 votes last time. If we count the people that voted for Aiden - around 200 - as those that are only interested in the Aiden path, so don't care about the boarding school path in which the Twist is relevant, that's only around 200 people. Of around 2000, so 10%.
Plus, we don't know if they're lowest tier or highest. If most of those supporters are Rookie patrons at the lowest level, then the loss is hardly significant.
I'm also only talking about the loss of Dylan supporters, because Dylan is the only character that has the story changed for their benefit. You don't hear Ellie fans complaining that an event should be removed because it makes her look bad. The Ellie/Julia event made Ellie look like a manipulative bitch. But I and others have never said it should be changed or removed.