Alley_Cat I admire and respect your commitment to keeping everything straight for us, providing clarity where things are uncertain or obscured. But I gotta say, you give me trauma, man. Every time you list out the fact that Dylan has four or five love interests I just freeze up and think, why the fuck does AWAM have five love interests for the son, three for the daughter, and two for Sam.
I get that he's designed this around mutually exclusive routes. Even given that some of these overlap, aren't we still looking at a very silly number of permutations? By my reckoning (which is very suspect, I admit), there are 13 combinations of Dylan/Ellie relationships if Sophia does not get involved with either of her kids:
Ellie Routes | Dylan Routes | | |
Ellie/Dylan | XX | XX | XX |
Ellie/Sam | Dylan/Emma | Dylan/Marie | Dylan/Amber |
Ellie/Jules | Dylan/Emma | Dylan/Marie | Dylan/Amber |
Ellie/Logan | Dylan/Emma | Dylan/Marie | Dylan/Amber |
I don't know if Ellie being with Sam, Jules or Logan makes any of Dylan's options impossible, so please correct me if I got this wrong.
Then, we can multiply these thirteen options by each of the paths available for Sophia where she doesn't pursue her kids:
Sophia/Liam |
Sophyia/Liam/Cathy/Andy |
Sophia/Nathalie |
Sophia/Zac |
Sophia/Alyssa |
Sophia/Patricia |
So that's 13 x 6, 78 variants of the story. Multiply by two because there are two side jobs, 156.
Even if you knock off a few of the 13 Dylan/Ellie permutations and maybe two or three of the Sophia routes (exclusive of her kids) are taken out, let's say it's actually 9 x 3 x 2, still 54 permutations.
And to that we have to add back in the Sophia+Ellie, and Sophia+Ellie+Jules, so that's two times the three Dylan relationships, and then there's Dylan + Sophia multiplied by the other three Ellie relationships, both multiplied by the two side jobs, so 12 + 6, another 18 permutations.
So 72 or 174.
I don't know about how mutual exclusivity pans out and what relationships make other relationships impossible, and maybe I'm over inflating all this, let's just say there's comfortably more than 50 different possibilities, and we havent yet factored in any of these golden nuggets:
How many Aiden tasks did you complete, did you get involved with Morello, are Vicky and DeShawn still in play, how much movin did the movers get done, subway thuggery - did it happen and how did it resolve, how will you respond to Bennett (I know we're never getting there but just for the sake of argument), and probably even more branches/dialogue-impacting decisions and variants I have, quite rightly, completely overlooked because how on earth could anyone (other than
Alley_Cat , a hero and a legend of this forum) keep this shit straight.
And, we've got 17.7 playable days left to sort this shit out.
Am I wrong in thinking this is a complete and total cluster fuck?