I was reading and catching up with the thread, and then I had this thought, which turned into more thoughts.
AWAM should've been the following choices only...
1) faithful to Liam, good wife path, simple yes or no choice, if no, then 2 or 3 choices available, if yes, then no 2 or 3 choices
2) Dylan or/and Sam's story path
"and" would mean lead to multiple sex partners at one time (3somes etc), "or" would be separate and no multiple
simple yes or no choice to this content
3) Lesbian route (Ellie + Alyssa + Emily + Patricia)
simple yes or no to each with Sophia
Everything else just happens, there are no 12 tasks, it's just Aiden being Aiden in the classroom and Sophia plays along if she agrees to both Dylan and Sam in option 2, so multiple needs to be chosen.
There is no major MR Bennett or casino Morello story, just brief things that help corrupt Sophia more, same with everything else, the maid, postman, the side jobs, going to the sauna with friends.
no points system, everything just happens linear based on the simple choices you make in 1-3.
I think this is how I would've down this story but the benefit of hindsight is always easier.