This is quite an emotional rollercoaster, and while there are sex scenes, I actually didn't jack it once because I wanted to get on with the story. There will be endless SPOILERS BELOW because I want to explain the journey I went on as how I would have rated the game fluctuated a fair bit.
So first up the boring bits: The game looks amazing, there's a range of pretty girls, the renders are great, there's lots of images so rather than people being frozen in place as you talk to them it felt more connected, fitting music, etc. That would normally lead to me saying the game is well polished, and it is in those regards, but, especially considering it 's a completed release, I really wan't expecting it to crash as often as it did, I've played a bunch of unfinished games and never had them completely close down like that, but thankfully you could just load up the last autosave and skip to where you got to.
So. I started this as I would any game on this site... telling everyone I wanted to date them and trying to fuck every lady I could. But this isn't some kinda corruption/blackmail/harem/rapey game so that hit me a bit wrong. I'd learnt that Liam was a great dude (and some stuff later on made me even happier I'd taken this approach) and I liked Melissa (not just because she was the prettiest but I also liked her and wanted to take care of her, quite unlike Meghan), so I decided to restart focusing on those 2...
And this is where my problems with the game began. I decided not to offer Meghan help, but she shows up on my doorstep anyway, fair enough, then when my bro is telling me off for sleeping with Melissa there's no option to say it's not cheating because I'm not going to pursue Meghan. Despite choosing every non-relationshipy option I could I had to end up dating Meghan, even when turning down other girls I had to say it was to be faithful to her. I really hated this. Having my character say and do the opposite of what I want was just a crappy frustrating experience, at that point the game would have been a 2 in my mind.
So I somehow end up in a threeway relationship with the understanding there'll be a big upcoming talk and I'll have to choose, so this has dragged out too long, I'm exicted to finally get rid of Meghan ... turns out even in that conversation I don't have the choice to do it.
I feel this Meghan aspect was completely forced on me just to try to make a later event particularly dramatic, but honestly I was rather relieved by that point.
So why am I giving it 4 stars? Because the game ended up being much more about my relationship to Liam for me. I love that guy, and wish I had a friend as good as that in my life. I was genuinely laughing at all the shit he'd do, and as the game went on I just got happier and happier about my decision to try and always be the best friend to him that I could before anything else. Also I didn't see the ending twist coming, I'm not sure how necessary it was, but it was at least unexpected.
So yeah, great graphics and music, some crashes, a forced relationship that frustrated, but a damn good friend to get some laughs and hang out with... and I ultimately got an ending I could live with too and am writing this with a warm fuzzy glow... which kinda makes me not want to see what happens if I go back and change some of those choices because I get the feeling that it has the potential to all go horribly wrong.