Honestly, i was gonna answer seriously and maybe have an interesting debate with you but I don't want to debate with someone who genuinely think that kidnapping, raping, drugging, enslaving people is better than overreacting over a theft.
Kate is evil. Sure. Now look at Isabelle in the locker event:
✔ Willing to kill an innocent cat out of petty revenge.
✔ Pissing on the face of someone after what's effectively sexual abuse towards that person.
✔ Killing someone by drowning, as a consequence of her actions.
The only atennuating factor in this shit is that it was Maxine's homunculus, not Maxine herself, but Isabelle had no way to know it.
When it comes to sexual abuse, both are peas of the same pod. But I don't recall Kate effectively killing someone, or willing to kill an innocent critter.
If someone is tempted to say "but isabel has gucci intenshuns!", go join Hell's paving corps. And ask yourself if Isabelle would take someone else's intentions into account before "IMMA DOIN JUSTEESSE!"
Also note that, as I said, in the specific case of her petty fight with Kate, I tend to side with Isabelle. As in: I'm not excusing Kate, far from that. I'm saying that Isabelle clearly causes
overall more harm than Kate does.
(I wonder if, pre-time loop, Isabelle wasn't in a jail.)
( I will just add on a side note that seeing a person steal your thing in a video is not an assumption, and the MC saw lindsey and tells Isabelle )
The assumption in question is that Lindsey stole Isabelle's
locker, not the chocolate hearts. This is clear by context and you're making a fool of yourself.
[I don't believe that I'm recommending this in a thread about a porn game, but: for anyone interested, check
You must be registered to see the links
. Then look at Isabelle.]