I think it kinda REALLY matters that a dev who's goal was to make a game with a trans positive character decided to cowtail to a small group who were actively transphobic in the thread. That'd be like if a bunch of people got mad that Cha'relle was in the game and the dev decided to lynch her if you don't pursue the romance route.
Like, I KNOW there are racist AF games like that on this site, but I'd still feel some type of way if a dev started a game trying to be positive toward a group, and then go 100% "phobic" due to some nasty comments.
Indeed, I could see Luxee as he is now doing exactly that and it would get the same response from me. It would be the same kind of negatively emotionally charged reactionary addition that this was and one that does not belong or ever did.
Isn't that game already complete ?
WAS already complete, Luxee decided to add more.
The Nea suicide is hamfisted bullshit. Ya'll can defend it all you want but the way it happened is shitty. You can argue "her life was hell' and all that garbage all you want. The fact that she kills herself after rejection is just wrong and stupid and selfish. Suicide harms the people you love. Bottom line. I know. The emotional baggage that she would leave the MC after that scene is unconscionable. He barely knows her and now has to shoulder the burden of being catalyst to her suicide? That shit is rough. I also do not think it fits the rest of the tone of the game so far regardless of dev intent. Best thing is to admit it was poorly written and retcon.
I was being nice about it and definitely wouldn't have put it in those exact words even at my worst, but this sums it up in the most direct way possible. I agree, it needs to be retconned. The intent is actually fairly obvious, the rest of the player base having to go through such a horrible thing is collateral damage for a reaction to haters, plain and simple.
On second thought you might be right on the retcon. Just remove her entirely. It was very poorly written and handled anyway.
P.S.: And just cuz it COULD happen in real life doesn't mean I want to see it in my porn games lol. Like I said...hamfisted bs.
However, this I do not agree with. I still want Nea, what I don't want is to be at fault for Nea's suicide just because I didn't want to be a suicidal person's lover.
I respect everyone's opinion on the whole Nea debate and it's great that people are so vested in it. Having said that, please can we stop beating this horse... it's been dead a long time now!
You are aware that new people who run face first into it and don't like it are just going to keep it going even if existing people stop, right? Your request for it to stop can only possibly apply to existing people due to the comment first mentality of some, which would bypass your comment entirely.
I am hoping that after doing the PL update, Luxee will feel like returning to the sisters and mother here. The reason the Nea debate rages is that Nea is really the only route in the game right now. You have bits of other routes, but the most fleshed out is Nea and without restarting the debate, there is plenty of reason to be unhappy with the way that route's choices end up.
Yes and no, the debate is largely over how it ends if you don't go the romance route with Nea, but it is certainly a contributing factor that Nea is a large chunk of current content and is a requirement for several other characters.
Yeah, that's the thing. There's not much to talk about with regards to other characters. We get lots of speculation of what might happen, but we've really had little interaction with many of the other characters. The design of the game has us just hitting important memories, but kind of missing out on character-building opportunities, or conversations that are more casual but still ultimately important. The only other character with content is... Alicia, I think her name is? The token "you can have sex with her while the story is developing" character. I'm not opposed to that idea in general, except I don't find Alicia appealing at all. There are other characters with potential, but that's all it is right now. Or we have some stuff that is rapidly escalating despite very little build up in the game, because we're just hitting high points in the relationship. PL had some rapidly escalating stuff contextually, but there was also story there and conversations and things like that.
I do think Luxee will be somewhat refreshed after the next update for PL. They may change their focus in A69 for a bit as well, especially given the controversy. I think other characters do need to have their stories advanced to level out the game a bit. But I'd also like to see more depth to it and character development for the other characters.
I don't even have enough to comfortably speculate on other characters with, for me, any speculation would just go to Nea anyway due to the overwhelming amount of content Nea has compared to the rest. Due to the obvious, that is not the best place for my own speculation to go at the moment.
idk it feels to me that if you hate a character enough to spend 70 pages talking about how much you hate them for being trans, then you should just move on to a different game and shut the fuck up. Like you're not talking about the game and if a mod saw people talking about sandboxes generically for more than a page they'd prune that shit down; I've seen them do it in that exact scenario before.
like, you're talking about this like we're talking about a single post or two, I'm talking about pages and pages of off topic repetitive whining that a character even exists in the game, so much so that the dev just had her jump off a roof in the last update. It's a problem, and I'm not even here that often.
That is most certainly what they should do if they can't reconcile their dislike for the one character in question and move on with the game. When the whining is so bad that the developer even adds something to the game as a reaction, that's a problem and that is when people need to leave the thread for a game they actually like. At that point, they have reached a level of dislike for the game itself that cannot be overcome enough to enjoy the game, the game simply isn't for them.
Except most of the talk isn't about hating Nea for being trans. The dominating topic is that it's messed up that Nea dies on the friendship route precisely because people wanted to help Nea, but at the same time not necessarily have sex with her. There are transphobic people here saying transphobic stuff, but you're over-representing how much that is. As I've said before, criticism of a trans character or their story is not necessarily transphobic, although some are taking that way. Maybe they think they are standing up for trans people, but putting them on a pedestal and believing they can do no wrong ultimately hurts them in the long run. Trans people are people that just happen to have the word "trans" in front. They're not worse than anyone else, but they're not better. They have flaws, they make mistakes. They can be horrible people or heroes, or sometimes both or neither.
As people point out, Nea is the main love interest in this game, despite assurances that the content was also optional, which is part of the debate about how well exactly that is working. Most of the content is about them. So most of the discussion is going to be about them and also what they did in the last update.
Indeed, the majority of the issue as I have seen it is also talking about Luxee's reaction and how messed up it was to make Nea jump off the roof over being rejected just because some players reacted unnecessarily harshly, not the initial cause. People wanting to help Nea weren't the reason Nea was made to jump, it was reaction to the people that wanted Nea to go through even worse things than Nea already had just because Nea is trans. It is misrepresentation, but only because the jump blew up in discussion, not because of how little the cause of the jump being added actually was, but because of how many people didn't want Nea to die and actually cared for Nea. It was by no means substantial, but there were a few incessant people talking bad about Nea for being trans.
You're right, Nea was supposed to be optional in terms of sex and the point we were led to believe was the point where we could choose not to go all the way to sex was exactly where the choice to kill Nea off was set with no way other than the sex path to keep Nea alive. That's what caused Nea's suicide to blow up even more than the cause of the jump being added.