Griev

Active Member
Game Developer
Dec 7, 2021
888
2,325
John's a cop so him being a racist is to be expected (he makes another comment in passing with a "Miss Ethiopia" gag that was dated 30 years ago), everyone else being fine with it less so. I was more surprised by Jessica joining in out of nowhere with the "30 pieces of silver" crack.
Ahh.
Cops being hateful pieces of shit would actually make more sense than it just being random hate speech, but yea I agree. Jessica joining in on it doesn't have that same excuse. There's no hint or previous cases of her having these thoughts prior to this.
 

manticore124

Newbie
Dec 14, 2018
44
109
So a writer can't write a tragic backstory for a character because it says "Hi I'm the author and I am depressed or suicidal or psychotic?" You might have shit in your head instead of a brain, get off the internet man.
Dude, it is so out of character. It's like if a character is talking in a movie and suddenly looks at the camera and says "Jews, amirite?" and then the scene goes on as if it never happened. Not gonna lie, it was so out of left field that I started laughing, but I really doubt that was the author intention.
 
  • Like
Reactions: gregers

xert13

Active Member
Sep 24, 2023
692
1,260
You're trying to make the case that the creator of a character has the same beliefs.....

So, a writer creates a rape scene, the writer must be a rapist.

We've got a shit load of incest games around, must be a ton of devs fucking their families.

George RR Martin created Game of Thrones and that has some sick characters in it, he needs locking up to protect humanity.

The entire Witcher franchise has a heavy racist undertone with the persecution of none humans. Not only is the writer of the books scum but so are all those writers for the games. Shame on them for their real life racism.....

Devs, writers, artists, actors and various other kinds of creators and performers come up with characters and scenes of pure fiction. To think character and creator are one and the same is ridiculously stupid.
Exactly. Extend it further - if you watch said scenes or prefer VNs that have loli or incest content, for example, than you must be a pedo. If you download stories with NTR than you are automatically a cuck. That is what some on these forums imply. Tiresome.
 

DIRTY FILTHY Animal

Devoted Member
Jun 11, 2020
9,651
33,372
You're trying to make the case that the creator of a character has the same beliefs.....

So, a writer creates a rape scene, the writer must be a rapist.

We've got a shit load of incest games around, must be a ton of devs fucking their families.

George RR Martin created Game of Thrones and that has some sick characters in it, he needs locking up to protect humanity.

The entire Witcher franchise has a heavy racist undertone with the persecution of none humans. Not only is the writer of the books scum but so are all those writers for the games. Shame on them for their real life racism.....

Devs, writers, artists, actors and various other kinds of creators and performers come up with characters and scenes of pure fiction. To think character and creator are one and the same is ridiculously stupid.
You mean Stephen King isn’t really the clown Pennywise from “It” and hides in a sewer to kill kids? :ROFLMAO:
 

xert13

Active Member
Sep 24, 2023
692
1,260
And this was probably one of the most pointless replies I've seen.


No. What about what I typed would indicate that I had a problem with Jews?


A writer CAN do anything they won't, but just as you are free to respond to my comment with an intellegent reply, others are free to comment on their work. Especially when random anti-Jew dialogue is added in a porn game. I'm here to fap, not to rag on a group of people tbh. If you can't except that other people may have different opinions than you may have YOU might be the one that should log off the internet, Man.
Sorry, but I do not see how the 30 pieces of silver comment is antisemitic. It is a literary reference from the Bible. Guess the Bible was antisemitic. If the character said, “Yeah, Erica is his White Whale” would that be a fat shaming comment? Anti whale hunting? Pro whale hunting? Lara is really in a Catch-22. Anti-military? Again, I just don’t see it.
 

Griev

Active Member
Game Developer
Dec 7, 2021
888
2,325
You're trying to make the case that the creator of a character has the same beliefs.....

So, a writer creates a rape scene, the writer must be a rapist.

We've got a shit load of incest games around, must be a ton of devs fucking their families.

George RR Martin created Game of Thrones and that has some sick characters in it, he needs locking up to protect humanity.

The entire Witcher franchise has a heavy racist undertone with the persecution of none humans. Not only is the writer of the books scum but so are all those writers for the games. Shame on them for their real life racism.....

Devs, writers, artists, actors and various other kinds of creators and performers come up with characters and scenes of pure fiction. To think character and creator are one and the same is ridiculously stupid.
None of those are porn games though. Porn game devs tend to create within the genres that appeal to their personal interests/kinks, with the hopes others that have the same interests will give it a shot and enjoy it. There's tons of raceplay games on this site. You think its created by people that have no interest in that genre? If GRRM made GoTs into a porn game and played up the incest kink even MORE, you wouldn't question whether the dude had a slight kink for it?
I wasn't really implying that someone that writes about murder, is a murderer as a direct correlation to their work. You're smart enough to understand that.
Look, I get what you're saying, and you're ultimately correct that a writer's work doesn't HAVE to seen as a direct reflection of their personal beliefs. But, if I'm playing a porn game and I'm mid fap and then randomly see some racist shit outta no where like a fuckin RKO, that has no relevance to the story AND includes a character that never shown to have those beliefs previously, I'm gonna start the wonder why it was placed there. (post fap, of course)
Lastly, lets not pretend that hateful individuals don't/can't create great content.
 

gregers

Forum Fanatic
Dec 9, 2018
5,068
6,569
Sorry, but I do not see how the 30 pieces of silver comment is antisemitic. It is a literary reference from the Bible.
It specifically references a Jewish man, Judas Iscariot, betraying the Christian Messiah. It has a looong history of being used as an anti-semitic trope, tied to the racist stereotype of Jews being particularly greedy and untrustworthy.
 

Griev

Active Member
Game Developer
Dec 7, 2021
888
2,325
Sorry, but I do not see how the 30 pieces of silver comment is antisemitic. It is a literary reference from the Bible. Guess the Bible was antisemitic. If the character said, “Yeah, Erica is his White Whale” would that be a fat shaming comment? Anti whale hunting? Pro whale hunting? Lara is really in a Catch-22. Anti-military? Again, I just don’t see it.
I gotchu fam!
 

T4bbo

Member
Game Developer
Apr 23, 2017
215
2,422
Oh, version leaked! Time to grab some popcorn and enjoy comments!

Btw. regarding lines used by Riverrun (writer) referring to Silver as being old Jew... I remember reviewing it and it didn't trigger anything for me, but I agree it feeds on stereotypes. I may change the wording if it triggers some hatred especially after escalation of Israel and Palestine conflict.

Good video from Ali on "Black" stereotypes that your comments reminded me:
 
Last edited:

Griev

Active Member
Game Developer
Dec 7, 2021
888
2,325
Oh, version leaked! Time to grab some popcorn and enjoy comments!

Btw. regarding lines used by Riverrun (writer) referring to Silver as being old Jew... I remember reviewing it and it didn't trigger anything for me, but I agree it feeds on stereotypes. I may change the wording if it triggers some hatred especially after escalation of Israel and Palestine conflict.

Good video from Ali on "Black" stereotypes that your comments reminded me:
Brilliant Ali video!
 

Joshy92

Message Maven
Mar 25, 2021
12,727
29,628
I really want to play this but I think I would enjoy it more if I wait for part 2.
I can't say I would have the same willpower to wait if Tyrone fucked Erica this update.
 
4.30 star(s) 105 Votes