Hello,
being a lover of this genre, I tought I could give a few feedback.
Innocent Witches (2D) => I've backed it for a while, but imo it's not Worth it. The art is very nice, in both the girls and the background, but the story is a real mess and the content so far scarce. I'd reccomend waiting for a more advanced version before trying this out. Also, while you are trying to mess with high school girls, the content in terms of BDSM is low.
Taffy tales => Loved it, it's Worth your time. It's one of these games which arouses not with the intrinsic sexyness of the models but rather with the situations it put you into. Not sure how I feel with the paranormal turning of the story though.
Cure My Addiction => Tried it briefly. The potential is there, but it seems overly complicated and grindy. Maybe I'll give it another shoot.
Love & Sex: Second Base => This has 2 scenes which are in my "best of" in terms of BDSM content, the atm with the anal beads and the peeing pet play (does this constitute a spoiler?). Apart from this though, I'd say L&S: SB is very tame.
Lust and Power => the forced "lesbian incest" is one of my go-to move for a quick fap, and the gameplay is not too bad. Mom and daughter aside, the other girls aren't Worth too much in terms of BDSM experience. As mentioned, updated are scarce.
My Legacy => "It's a no from me dwag"...harder to decipher than the Riddle of Master Lu, the BDSM level is very meh
Man of the House => Loved the game, but it should be mentioned that the BDSM part is quite short and takes some time to get to. Still Worth it.
Anna Exciting Affection => another game that I liked, but BDSM level afaik is very mild. Lot of other erotic situations though
The Tyrant => Untapped potential, Worth keeping an eye on
Lexi => I would up the title to AA at least, but as far as BDSM is involved, I don't recall emphasis on it. I may be wrong though
Personal Assistant => I haven't seen this mentioned, another game which may become a gem, but not anytime soon. The model is gorgeous (warning: borderline Young), but by chosing to spread is focus on 3 paths (good guy, corruption, sadistic), the dev is chewing more than he can handle. Also, the M/C is ugly. Like really ugly.
Something Unlimited by Gunsmoke => In my experience, one of the few "heroines corruption" game actually well made, featuring ladies from DC universe. It's a classic "trainer" game, pretty vanilla compared to Others, but still interesting.