VN - Ren'Py - Because I Love Her [Part 2 NTR Update] [The Typist]

Review of the 1.0 version (as I wanted a complete experience).

I really, really wanted to give this game five stars simply because I found it really hot, and also because it did a lot right. For reference, I played with NTR on.

What I really like about this game in the context of a NTR game is that it was extremely focused on the main couple, their dynamics, and, most of all, their communication. You can have all the outlandish promiscuity you can dream up, but conveying meaning and impact multiplies the eroticism tenfold, and, largely, this game did that. In addition, I found the scenes and renders hot in and of themselves, and the pacing of events was pretty good until the last 20% or so.

For the bad, well, bugs first off. There were several instances in which the primary couple's names were hard coded, as well as some in which secondary character names were mis-referenced.

The second and largest complaint has to do with several instances of extremely random plot control by the writer.

1. Spoiler

   You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
2. Spoiler

   You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
3. Spoiler

   You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
4. Overall, the author's writing discipline seemed to wane quite a bit towards the end, and it felt like they were simply trying to wrap up events by any means possible. My characters, who had communicated everything , were suddenly having a fight that was contradictory to all their previous discussions, they began making major decisions without communicating, and player choice was funneled down to a single path. For other events, setup and promise of completion was initiated, but never fulfilled. I get that these things take resources, and that writing is especially hard in the context of branching and rendering, but by the end I felt like I'd ridden an amazing roller coaster, and, smiling as we glided into the exit, a clown pied me in the face.

Such an amazing game.

Very hot renders and scenarios. Love it when it isn't cuck and actual swinging. The GF and her sis are especially hot. The pacing is excellent, as there is so much more potential as well.

My only gripe with these type of games is that the 'bull' is always black ; that trope is so overdone. Other than that, was a truly satisfying game. Even the writing was pleasant, as it really underscored the sexual psychology behind people in more open relationships.

This is a solid game with excellent renders and animations. It also has a pretty good somewhat slow-burn story that (to me at least) doesn't feel too rushed or cliche. There is also a decent amount of branching so your decisions will impact which scenes you see offering a bit of replayability. I only knock one star off due to the pace of development (over 5 years and not much content) which is unfortunate as I think most fans would love to see more from this dev as it is quality stuff.

This game is super hot to me, so I'm giving it a conditional 5 stars.

The condition is that new content comes out and progresses the story, this left me wanting so much more. It hit all the right NTR and cheating buttons.

Love it, keep it up.

Considering the age of the game it has very little content, even Ocean is left behind. But in quality it's nowhere near as good. Even considering that Dev made some kind of a remake, it's still too little.

Older version of the game was NTR/Cuck focused game, the new one seems lees focused on NTR, but you still can see that Dev enjoys creating exactly this type of content.

He probably wanted to get more supporters hence decided to play both sides (cuck/love). And when Dev who specializes on creating cuck content tries to integrate other paths - we get this game.
What do I mean by that:
- not appealing story;
- bold, empty characters (bad written), who acts abruptly, illogical;
- even on non-NTR path you still get cuckish vibers sometimes;
- writing could be polished (mildly saying) as well;

Obviously Dev sometimes is being at a total loss as how to progress the story that was supposed to be NTR-only, hence updates are very rare, only fully devoted subscribers will keep supporting him this way. My humble opinion - he should have held onto his original idea instead of trying to satisfy vanilla players, cause only few of them will play the game with periodical cuckish vibes.

MC is spineless cuck (but it is expected in a NTR focused game, which it was originally), for example Claire after meeting the BBC in the gym (almost love from the first sight lol) just out of a blue tells MC that she would like to have some fun with other guys (talking about absolutely abrupt behaviour from bad-written characters) and MC is like" "Of course darling, why not".
Anyway the game is just bad, it should have been left in it's original direction. In it's current stage I think it won't satisfy fully NTR lovers and vanilla players will be pissed too.

Only positive thing from here is that girl models are good, but that's it

Because I Love Her [Part 1-Ch.3]

Pros:
Character Models

Cons:
Boring Story
bad writing
Characters are not interesting
dialogues are dull
terribly slow pacing
very little content
little to no choices that matter
boring sex scenes
unlikeble male mc

Conclusion:
The 5* ratings pretty much have become a meme on this Site, because it seems to be enough to have good renders and the 5* are yours.
At least that's how I can explain that, because this game is nowhere near 4-5 stars.
It's incredible, that this game has been in development since 2018, and still offers so little content, and has a story that is so slow-burn, at a milking pace.
The story is so boring, just like the characters and their conversations between each other.
I guess this is supposed to be about NTR and sharing, but this game feels all over the place and also being nowhere.
What I mean by this is, that you often times switch between both MC's and click through many conversations and scenes, that offer little to no substance.
There is little to no action to be seen here, and the "corruption" part is really corny.
I really don't like the male MC. He seems like a spineless cuck.
You'd like to think that if this game focuses more on the visuals, it would at least offer good sex scenes.
But that is also not the case. The sex scenes are very few, really short and unmemorable.
All in all, this VN is a waste of time, that offers little to no substance, and will take a place on my ignore list.

First Because I love her was nice and had a good fantasy story with the succubus.

The new Because I love her is better and more realistic story.
I love the story build up and choices you get, a few spelling errors but those can be fixed.
The renders are very nice.
The models used for the women are very pretty.

Looking forward to the next updates of the game.

Definitely have a huge potential, the heroines are one of the prettiest I've ever seen in a game, and the relationship between Claire and the protagonist is something really cool, because they have a real talk about everything and this really feels good. Good job and keep going forward

when i played Because I Love Her for the first time (old versions) I feel a mix of feelings. The game has a large potential, but something was wrong. The final of the old version was a conclusion: a very bad ending.

I will rating based in the quality of ntr content here. I'm not design, so I will not judge the game for art (despite I'm not an idiot and I see that this art is well maded). I like good stories and good plots, I'm a enjoyer of good dialogues and these are what I will rate here.

I think games based on ntr have naturally a trouble: they don't understand what really the public who like ntr really like. So, I saw three forms: 1 - classical netorare - the typical game where the wife love the husband but is blackmailed or corrupted by other guy and is fucked without husband consent; 2 - netori - the worseful (in my opinion) form of ntr, the wife is literally a sociopath and cheat her husband without any guilty or remorse; 3 - netorase - similar to sharing and swinging. Finally the husband validation is a point, but it's not exactly like cuckolding.

In the end, ntr is the asiatic word for cuckolding, swinging or cheating, only that. But why exactly people want to be cheated? So, if anyone here search in forums for cuckolding, you will discover that some guys love to share their 'girls'. These guys feels excited while watching his wife being fucked by another dude. In another way, different from pornography content, these guys don't want to be cheated, they really want to SHARE their wives\gfs\dates. This is the first and most important step. After a good talk, the guy is honest, the girl will think about, and then their lifes will change for ever (or not)

Now, the roles: hotwife, cuck, bull. Even in a swing couple, is normal that the guy or the girl like to play as cuck\cuckqueen. The real point in this kink is playing with fire: feel excited with the insecurity. One guy with low stamine or small\average dick wants to see his girl being fucked by another guy who do it better than him. That's the motivation. This does not imply that he or she is a failure, a loser. Quite the opposite, most people who like to share are normal people, including successful people.

I think what's always been missing to because i love her was understand the roleplay inside of the opened reletionships. But being honestly the roles are not so rigid, and this is why I see a lot of potential here since ever: conversation is the basis of everything. There is a lot of synergy between the couple.

mercifully things are changing (not about because i love her, but about these games. Recently some devs are trying getting away from stereotypes and are trying to understand the roleplay. I'm talking about: couple's duet of love and lust;watching my wife and others.

I hope the developer fetch a good plot, what makes sense. I like the new version of the game, but I still think that roleplays should to be introduced. Of course, I don't expect a passive husband. I see a handsome husband and a lot of beautiful womans. I want to see every they naked hahaha.

I think the typist could created paths to please greeks and trojans: A harem or vanilla path for normies (sorry guys); soft-hotwifing for who like exibiothionism, swing\sharing without any humiliation; And finally a hardcore-hotwife path for the people who really enjoy cuckolding.

This remake is being a great improvement for the game. In the past I always think why the mc could like to share your wife, but he never enjoy it. My favourite scene was that sexygame where the black guy, the mc, his wife and her friend takes the clothes off and ending with the wife doing a blowjob in the black guy. That moment was amazing, but honestly: why the wife collapse and corrupt so fast? The funniest part in the cuckolding kink is the long arc where the wife turns herself in a hotwife. begnning, mid-game (WHEN THE FUNNY HAPPENS) and end-game (moral hangover?) You know? a passioned girl, who loved her husband corrupts and turn in a hot and kink female WITH her husband validation. And even for the husband, he should enjoy it too, he should go there with her AND other person.

So, 4 five stars with some ideas. Good game what could turn into a great game with a good script and plot.

Sorry for my not perfect english. I tried. Good job

I used to really love Because I Love Her for its bold look at NTR, and sharing. However, the newer version is moving at what could only be called a snail's pace.
Though the updated models/graphics are incredible, and the women do look hot, I am not enjoying the story. Even with the promise of some sharing scenes, I doubt we're going to get there anytime soon with how slow of a burn this is.
I am sorry, but I cannot recommend this game anymore. I had to change my score to a Poor to match the slow story/narrative.

if you don't like ntr but you do like cuckquean content this game may become your new favorite. Looking forward as to how the cuckquean content expands from here as it is a very under used genre currently. I'm looking forward to future updates.

This is a unique situation. The game "Because I Love Her" has two versions. The old version had some supernatural elements, heavy cuckolding, and inconsistent pacing. The new version is going for realism, minimal cucking, and only updates a handful of times a year.

If I was judging the original game, I'd give 4/5 stars because even though the story is mediocre, the visuals are hot and erotic.

If I'm judging the new game, I'd give it 2/5 star max, because although the graphics have improved greatly, there isn't much content to be enjoyed.

Truly, this thread is CARRIED by version 1 of the game and the numerous five stars it received. If the new version had to stand on its own, it would be an obscure trainwreck.

Great game and amazing art. The characters feel so real and the story is off to a great start. I've never seen so many beautiful characters in a game and I am excited for the different story options. Can't wait for updates.

Dev started making a visual novel a long time ago and had completely different ideas for the story than he does now. Or maybe he wasn't happy with the render quality and scenes of the original. Whatever the reason, it is being remade from scratch. Is it better than the original? I guess. But is the story worth remaking? Or the characters? Nah. Not by a long shot.

Basically the remake made NTR less of a focus. But it still has NTR. The people that dont like NTR dont want to play the game anyways, and putting less of a focus on it makes cucks annoyed too. Nobody is happy. Either axe it completely or leave it be and go balls to the walls with it dont half ass it

For cuckshit, play the original version for nice looking renders play the remake. But who plays for nice looking renders? Come on. The story is some nonsesne about a couple exploring their sexuality and life wooooaah thats so cool, nah it is bland basic stuff. Imagination has died, and all we are left with are a bunch of postmodernist devs showing of their daz tech skills. Hire a writer, or get some geek with a great plot+characters and let him tell you the story. This drama with nothing happening with bland people with character traits ranging from virgin to prostitute that wants to get tagteamed by 6 suburban sasquatches does nothing but make my finger hold down the CTRL key.

You have childhood friend that wants to jump your bones, your gf is a whore and then you have several other people that you dont give a solitary F about that also low key for some reason want to lick your armipits. Why? I have no idea. You are just a regular dude but also really nice and cool and stuff I guess and that makes the ladies panties wet. I get that its going for the harem MC thing, but you have to pick a lane, either the MC is great and everyone wants a piece or nobody wants a piece and he gets cucked. One or the other, these are mutually exclusive

All in all, a massive waste of time just from an outsiders point of view. I mean you can skim through the original version AND the remake in half an hour. How many sex scenes in that time? Maybe 5. It is barren in content, the remake did salvage the story from complete degen trash to ok degen trash, but the only proper way to go would have been to take the assets you had (Claire), and start a visual novel entirely, with new characters, setting and story. But instead it is being remade. Hurray for mediocrity

Oh yeah, and at one point a succubus arrives. Because magic. And no it did not make the story better just made it even more confusing

-EDIT: Updated rating to 3 stars after having played most recent version. When I first played the current remake, it was indeed very very short, thus my review below was accurate. Now, the same comments stand, but without the gripe about length.


I look at all these other reviews and wonder if I'm playing a different game, or clicked wrong download link by mistake.

The entire game is like 20 minutes long, no? There's maybe 5 major scene groups. Whether you like or dislike the story doesn't really matter because it's over in a few minutes.

I guess if I had to be objective the render art is good, and dialogue sounds believable, but again, I must repeat myself, it's like 20 minutes long! I suppose it's a good start to a project, but this is nowhere near even a partially completed game, it feels like an alpha teaser of an alpha.

New version of the game is really good as of now and the game have really good character 's but the developer need be constant it updated or else some news about the game in this of version we can final have some good romance path good for non ntr fans compared to last version this version is really good hope the developer won't rush this game

Well this one is difficult to review. Generally it has nice genders a pretty attractive females. The story in chapter one is interesting but has a lot of flaws. For example John sometimes behave totally pathetic and sometimes like fully in control. There is a lot of options but just few which directs you where you want the story to go. In chapter 1 is poorly managed sex scenes. Like one click is starting the scene and the second "finished, i needed that". Chapter 2 has improved this scenes but so far the story is barely related to chapter 1 and not really catching for now.

New version is all about character building and making a better story. Also splitting the romance (non-ntr) and ntr path so they are basically two different games. This way, those who want romance will never have to deal with ntr whatsoever, while those who want ntr, will get plenty of it on a different path. Now they shouldn't mesh together like before.

Writing the review about chapter 2 which is a remake of the whole story we have seen so far and in comparison with the previous game its a totally different experience for example the renders are very high quality the game offers way more choices that change the flow of the story NTR is avoidable and balanced .If you had a bad experience with the previous game i recommend trying the new version the creator has done a pretty good job in this one .

Unfortunately, this game has bigger smoke than flame so far ..and compared that it's already a remake, it became quite faint. I'm not saying there's a problem with the basic story, but so far it’s almost exactly the same as the previous game started.
You have a beautiful girlfriend, Claire, who starts going to the gym with Olivia while the MC is usually asleep until two in the afternoon. You also have a roommate, Jenni, who you can peek at times while she change.

There are already a bit more actors in the game than in the previous one, but on the amount of content and the pace of the game, it is clearly visible that focusing on the love and the NTR route at once is already too much stress for the dev.
As an NTR fan, I can't really talk about the harem path, but so far neither about NTR, because it's not really exist in the game (yet). But in fact I wasn't really bothered coz of this, because there is nothing wrong with a story (even if it's NTR) what is building up slowly and gradually. The problem is more with the lack of creativity on the NTR line.
I'm not exaggerating if I'm saying that the previous game was much better then this second one in many ways until the arrival of the succubus (or rather until Claire's first real sex scene with Darryl). The story in the previous wasn't so lifelike everywhere, but it wasn't boring for a minute. And unlike the second.. on the first game you had that feeling yet, the dev worked on it without any pressure.

Overall, the second game so far is like it not being able to step out of the shadow of the old one. Ofc it's also starts on the same disappointing interracial way, where Clare meets the biggest black bull in the town, and then the chemistry starts working among them right away. But the difference in both games is that in the second one as I said earlier, we barely have real NTR content so far, and the story rather looks like the dev is just already rushing through the events, coz unlike in the first game, he doesn’t want to get stuck already on the details, which could maybe improve on the story.
While in the previous game we could experience those exciting NTR feelings like the cheating, jealousy, or just simply the risk of being caught in the shower with Darryl ..until then in the new game, Claire, almost from the nothing just suddenly brings up the topic as an idea, she should try some fun with other guys as well. And the MC's reaction was like.. yes Babe why not..
The game got to the point almost without any precedent... It’s like they’ve been in an open relationship since the beginning.. But if so, why does the game ask about the NTR content, if it's actually just a swinging one?!

But towards the end of the second chapter we still have a little netorase event, where Claire shows herself half naked to perfect strangers in the park.. but seriously... Cmon dev.. you are much more creative than this..
But even that one scene was ruined by the one sentence from Claire: "My boyfriend is watching us". This made the whole scene embarrassing.

Unfortunately the game was nowhere near as good as I expected, but it is still in the beginning, so it may improve. I really hope that the game will finds its way back to the path I loved so much in the first one.