@King Monkey Mon &
@Eerie Entity
For me, it's: Josy, Jill, Sage and Riona. Each of them are at the top of my list for various reasons...
To be honest, if I were the MC (and this were real life) I wouldn't trust any of them (so an actual relationship would be out of the question) but, I'd be having as much fun as possible. That being said, here's my short list so far.
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
Josy = Cute "girl next door" even though she's willing to cheat on her boyfriend (or so it seems).
Jill = Attractive and caring. Comes across as having a lot more (intelligence, etc) inside than she lets on.
Sage = Flirty redhead with a jealous streak. (I highly doubt she's a "good person" but, I've never had a boring relationship with a redhead, though they typically end in tears, chaos and destruction.)
Riona = She's the closest to my "ideal" physically plus, the tattoos work for her. She's guarded (mostly quiet) which makes her seem like she's either rather intelligent or "just following along." Not sure which is the case, yet so she's (for now) at the bottom of my list.