Casiope

Member
Nov 30, 2017
199
755
The thing with Heather is strange. She clearly says to the MC so she's just using him. After all, she already did that in EP8.

I figure so Heather wants to make Tommy jealous. Tommy is already sick of it so the MC is good at everything. But Tommy, I think, won't even mind if the MC fucks Heather because then he can keep fucking around. Tommy will mind it more because the MC can be honest with Heather, thus giving her the idea of a relationship change. Tommy definitely doesn't want that.

My guess is so that in EP10 on the MJ path, Tommy will snap and Heather, who is still at the Mansion, will take sides with Josy, Maya and the MC because she wants that herself loyalty from Tommy.
There are three Heathers at the end of episode 9:
  • The one who fulfilled her desire for payback.
  • The one that we declined without insulting the future.
  • Finally the one that we rejected forever.
These three Heathers are likely to have different inclination, but a common plot would have to go through a separation with Tommy for the main character to be morally blameless. To put it simply, I assume Heather is not only for players on the Single branch with DIK affinity.
 
Last edited:

Mmoney7187

Member
Sep 30, 2017
192
412
Don't worry, no one will die. The valiant watermelon man will not allow this. But his name (Tybalt) we'll keep it a secret.
View attachment 2295810
The watermelon will take a valiant dive in front of the bullet shot by Vinny after the MC seduces it away from Tybalt when it sees the dick pic on Tybalt's phone. It will turn out to be just a graze and will live happily ever after!

DISCLAIMER-(No fruit used for self pleasure were harmed in the writing of this fan fic)
 

robrize2169

Well-Known Member
Oct 8, 2022
1,610
3,340
best scene in the game so far is when Sally goes off on Tybalt for interrupting their game. MC tells Sally he liked her more after that. i think Sally will end up falling for the mc if he treats her right since Magnar is a boring guy and only cares about studying while we can see that Sally is more and more becoming a party girl and needs a guy that wants to party with her. once she gets a look at MC's dick, she will be all over him. and that's fine cause she is hot as fuck.
 

The Glorious LIME

Well-Known Member
Oct 20, 2019
1,747
9,678
WHAT IF: What do you all think about the following?

If MC's College life started with running into a high Tommy that got into his face and MC deck'd him to the floor, the Alpha's would've probably invited him due to that.
How do you guys think he'd fit in the Alphas? I actually think that Anthony is a decent dude, just dumb. Derek's a bigger retard than him by far. And I think Chad and MC would work well together, since Chad seems like an ok dude too tbh.

Without MC, the DIK's would be dead in the water tbh.
 

The Glorious LIME

Well-Known Member
Oct 20, 2019
1,747
9,678
Didn't Chad and the Jocks give MC a wedgie in episode 1 which basically started the whole conflict? :LUL:
That's why I said, what if his college life started with decking Tommy.
Besides, nowadays in the game Chad and MC are fine with each other, Chad even says so. And Chad only did so due to MC getting in his face due to Sage.

I'm just interested in an alternate timeline, how do you see MC in the Jocks? I think they would be pretty damn unstoppable tbh. The DIKs are complete shit without MC. While Jocks still function even with the leader gone, so to speak.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mmoney7187

Geralt From Rivia

Forum Fanatic
Jun 15, 2022
5,358
32,751
I'm not criticizing your disliking because I didn't like it too, but I think it fits her personality... If there was a girl who would do such a thing, that would be Jill. But that's the fun of the game: choose a girl whose personality appeals to you. If they were all the same, it would be only a matter of picking the most pretty of them or even going for a harem. I think this was coherent with her beliefs, whether we like it or not... The best we can do is forgive her or abandon her path... I think we have even less to complain about since MC's reaction almost fits the description of your complaints. I even reviewed the scene as a chick, agreeing with her and Burke it was bullying, and not defending Chad, and the only difference is, on the DIK route, Tremolo says: "You treated me like a fucking kid!" That is, even as a chick, the MC never agrees with Jill's actions. I think those who, in the real world, as players, agree with Jill's actions or think MC's attitude was not compatible with a chick role have more to complain about because they're not able to, as players, react the way it would be more coherent to the personality they're giving to their MC. This was, IMHO, Mr. DPC's greatest sin in this sequence (and others he denied an MC's response compatible with his affinity) and not the way he did Jill behave.
Yes, it is clear that all girls are unique and different, for each type of personality there is something different. And this is good, because then the game would not have been so popular and the fans would not have written 11 thousand pages in disputes and theories here.
I also think that sometimes MC behaves out of character, depending on the affinity. There are a lot of differences, for example, his behavior is different in dialogues, CHICK is more polite, DIK is relaxed and a little rude. But in some moments ... there are script flaws.
 

Mmoney7187

Member
Sep 30, 2017
192
412
That's why I said, what if his college life started with decking Tommy.
Besides, nowadays in the game Chad and MC are fine with each other, Chad even says so. And Chad only did so due to MC getting in his face due to Sage.

I'm just interested in an alternate timeline, how do you see MC in the Jocks? I think they would be pretty damn unstoppable tbh. The DIKs are complete shit without MC. While Jocks still function even with the leader gone, so to speak.
I could def see it maybe instead of defending Sage you defend Heather in the beginning and that's how conflict with the DiKs starts, the only thing that would suck in this alt timeline is missing out on the bromance with Derrick and having Sage as a LI from the start.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Derpyyz

NebulousShooter

Engaged Member
Donor
Oct 24, 2018
3,213
22,406
Yes, it is clear that all girls are unique and different, for each type of personality there is something different. And this is good, because then the game would not have been so popular and the fans would not have written 11 thousand pages in disputes and theories here.
I also think that sometimes MC behaves out of character, depending on the affinity. There are a lot of differences, for example, his behavior is different in dialogues, CHICK is more polite, DIK is relaxed and a little rude. But in some moments ... there are script flaws.
and Jill is for 40yo virgins, nothing wrong with that :Kappa:
 

JaxMan

Active Member
Apr 9, 2020
715
642
Others have already written what I wanted to say, but I can add something.
I don't like how Jill took care of the MC in the first season. For example, she gathered a pedagogical council because of the MC/Chad fight and complained about it. I don't like Chad and in the end he got what he deserves according to the script, but:
1. What right does she have to decide for Tremolo? She is not his mother.
2. It was a dangerous move and under other circumstances she would have painted a target on his back.
3. She exposed MC as a child in need of care.

I have other answers that I don't like about her behavior.

And it's not hate, just fun and memes.
Jill acted out in a mature way when she saw bullying...twice. Remember the Jocks wedgied the MC and then initiated a fight. From what little we know from Jill's path, she was bullied and you get the impression nobody stood up for her. That's her reaction, bullying should be reported. Sure the MC didn't like it because he was somewhat selfish in that he didn't want to make waves or draw attention to himself. From his point of view, since he suffered from bullying as well, you ignore it or fight back. So you have conflicting perspectives, report bullying when you see it and ignore it/fight back.

Nothing about her being a mother and she didn't expose the MC as a child. She was attempting to stop a pattern of bullying that if left to itself would cause problems for both. Looking at the big picture, has the MC been bullied by the Jocks since Chad was punished? Would they have continued if they got away with it, i.e. not reported, probably. Now as a DIK he has a crew for support so he only gets bullied by Tommy now. Without the frat he has nobody watching his back and would have been bullied until he did something extreme to stop it and probably been suspended (remember his own story at school when he got suspended beating up the bully).
 

Geralt From Rivia

Forum Fanatic
Jun 15, 2022
5,358
32,751
Jill acted out in a mature way when she saw bullying...twice. Remember the Jocks wedgied the MC and then initiated a fight. From what little we know from Jill's path, she was bullied and you get the impression nobody stood up for her. That's her reaction, bullying should be reported. Sure the MC didn't like it because he was somewhat selfish in that he didn't want to make waves or draw attention to himself. From his point of view, since he suffered from bullying as well, you ignore it or fight back. So you have conflicting perspectives, report bullying when you see it and ignore it/fight back.

Nothing about her being a mother and she didn't expose the MC as a child. She was attempting to stop a pattern of bullying that if left to itself would cause problems for both. Looking at the big picture, has the MC been bullied by the Jocks since Chad was punished? Would they have continued if they got away with it, i.e. not reported, probably. Now as a DIK he has a crew for support so he only gets bullied by Tommy now. Without the frat he has nobody watching his back and would have been bullied until he did something extreme to stop it and probably been suspended (remember his own story at school when he got suspended beating up the bully).
I see your point of view, but I have to correct you in some ways.
Tommy doesn't bully MC. He is certainly rude, massive DIK, but this is not bullying. Tommy's behavior is that of a typical drill sergeant in the army towards a rookie. First when he was a maggot, now he trains MC in throwing parties.
Party planning is Tommy's job and MC is aiming for his spot. It makes perfect sense for Tommy to act this way.
Tommy: "You broke into my office, sat naked in my chair, scattered papers like a monkey, and now you're asking me to fix all the shit." The subtext is obvious. Sage also notices this and says "Tommy is being territorial and testing you" when MC complains. Smart girl, he should listen more often to what she says.
In fact, Tommy respects MC if you behave properly (in my case, I have a lot of "Tommy liked it" notes in the BIOS), my canon MC is DIK.
Tommy admires you and is a bit jealous, he doesn't want a repeat of the power struggle conflict. And only when he is drunk on the roof he says: "You made a hell of a party! Bravo Tremolo, Bravo!" Drunk people don't lie, as we know.
 
4.80 star(s) 1,538 Votes