I know I'm late to the party but I just had to do my very own tier list
This is actually the first one I have ever done here it is
View attachment 2990361
Your two S girls are both liars (by omission) and manipulators. I dropped them as soon as soon as its revealed they are in a relationship together.
Sage is alright, but has no personality other than her big tits. I find her to be the type of girl who thinks she is more than her looks but actually isn't. I dropped her.
The big boob librarian (I forget her name) suffers from the same flaws as Sage. She is a moppy depressing bitch whose only redeeming quality is massive tits. Dropped.
The Hots, are all cool but are all superficial and only care about looks and status. If MC wasn't in the dicks they wouldn't talk to him.
In contrast, Quinn is the perfect girl. Sure, she uses the MC but is always upfront about it. In other words, she allows the MC to decide if he will be used by her or not. Nice sense of homeostasis between them. Some may say Quinn is also superficial but I do not think thats true. I think Quinn is tired of pretending which is why MC has been getting closer to her as the game progresses.