Maya of all people should know how to treat someone yet there many times she is bad to Josy yet she treats MC much better then she ever does Josy. There only one scene where Maya acts like a good girlfriend and that if Josy wins best costume, would be nice if Maya could tell Josy thank you just once and instead of always feeling sorry for herself. I can't cut Maya slack when she hurting Josy
Because Maya fell in love with MC and she would be his girlfriend if Josy didn't turn up.
And if you choose the throuple relationship you would see that Josy favours MC over Maya and Maya favours MC over Josy.
And if you don't choose the throuple relationship and feel for Maya you would see that Maya regrets that she chose Josy over MC.
And if you don't choose the throuple relationship you would see that Josy regrets that she chose Maya over MC.
And if you don't choose the throuple relationship the game is hinting that they're arguing quite a bit.
You are misleading situations by telling that Josy is a best girlfriend because she's helping Maya, because any good friend / selfless person would do what she does for Maya: she's not doing it because she's her lover.
Anyway, she didn't do anything special: she just talked to a few people and asked for advice - she ain't giving her a kindney/her marrow and she didn't took out a mortgage.