Darkwen

Forum Fanatic
Nov 10, 2020
5,455
11,701
It doesn't help that even in the throuple, Josy clearly favors MC over Maya. There's less baggage with him, no looming threat over his head that threatens his and Josy's relationship. If things go south, he is a lifeboat with a big dick. Unfortunately, Maya seems to feel the same way, stating that she feels more comfortable with MC than she ever did with Josy. If the throuple is to succeed, it will be a delicate balancing act.

Honestly, unless I'm favoring Josy/still have feelings for Josy, I choose Maya every time in Episode 10. That way Josy gets to retain her dignity, and Maya is more fun than her for this particular hangout. I also like how she's supportive of MC and his new relationship, even if he dumped her. She doesn't hold a grudge against whoever it is, and can see why we chose them over her and Josy. It's also nice how she points out that she and MC are in the same boat if you're dating Bella, all four of them have to hide their relationships.
Personally I don't think the throuple is meant to succeed its suppose to come to a end. Both girls prefer MC over the other and even after months there relationship is still not good they don't even care that they didn't do anything for there anniversary which would had happen near the start of the game or during the summers months which would mean they wasn't together and even after being reunited they still didn't do anything. This relationship is meant to end with MC getting one of them
 

Geralt From Rivia

Conversation Conqueror
Jun 15, 2022
6,618
42,463
It doesn't help that even in the throuple, Josy clearly favors MC over Maya. There's less baggage with him, no looming threat over his head that threatens his and Josy's relationship. If things go south, he is a lifeboat with a big dick. Unfortunately, Maya seems to feel the same way, stating that she feels more comfortable with MC than she ever did with Josy. If the throuple is to succeed, it will be a delicate balancing act.

Honestly, unless I'm favoring Josy/still have feelings for Josy, I choose Maya every time in Episode 10. That way Josy gets to retain her dignity, and Maya is more fun than her for this particular hangout. I also like how she's supportive of MC and his new relationship, even if he dumped her. She doesn't hold a grudge against whoever it is, and can see why we chose them over her and Josy. It's also nice how she points out that she and MC are in the same boat if you're dating Bella, all four of them have to hide their relationships.
There is a theory that Josy/Maya will only be able to work successfully in Throuple if the MC made the right decisions, balancing them, and this seems plausible. Maya and Josy have very different personalities and it’s clear that the two of them don’t get along well.
Maya accepts the breakup very gracefully. Honestly, I didn't expect this. Previously, I thought that Maya would be the first to fall, knowing how vulnerable she was due to her situation and this would finish her off. But it was a very pleasant surprise and vulnerable girl in the constant victim status turned out to be much stronger. Experiencing her father’s pressure, it taught her that you can't be loved by force and can't control other people’s feelings. Such is life. She is tolerant, and to be honest, it’s good when you manage to maintain friendly relations with exes, without the usual “he/she is an asshole.” Maya has grown a lot in my eyes since Ep.10.
I will even say that Maya copes with a breakup better than anyone else, with full dignity. Sage and Isabella also cope well. It was hard for Jill, but damn, even Jill could do it! Jill! But for the full picture, I would like to see what Josy will be like in Episode 11 on this route. Can she make peace with MC? We'll see.
 

Joshy92

Message Maven
Mar 25, 2021
12,290
28,101
There is a theory that Josy/Maya will only be able to work successfully in Throuple if the MC made the right decisions, balancing them, and this seems plausible. Maya and Josy have very different personalities and it’s clear that the two of them don’t get along well.
Maya accepts the breakup very gracefully. Honestly, I didn't expect this. Previously, I thought that Maya would be the first to fall, knowing how vulnerable she was due to her situation and this would finish her off. But it was a very pleasant surprise and vulnerable girl in the constant victim status turned out to be much stronger. Experiencing her father’s pressure, it taught her that you can't be loved by force and can't control other people’s feelings. Such is life. She is tolerant, and to be honest, it’s good when you manage to maintain friendly relations with exes, without the usual “he/she is an asshole.” Maya has grown a lot in my eyes since Ep.10.
I will even say that Maya copes with a breakup better than anyone else, with full dignity. Sage and Isabella also cope well. It was hard for Jill, but damn, even Jill could do it! Jill! But for the full picture, I would like to see what Josy will be like in Episode 11 on this route. Can she make peace with MC? We'll see.
I think it was easier for Maya because she is used to being dissapointed.
 

Better Cock Spock

Half Vulcan, Half Simp
Donor
Jul 29, 2017
6,470
21,792
Personally I don't think the throuple is meant to succeed its suppose to come to a end. Both girls prefer MC over the other and even after months there relationship is still not good they don't even care that they didn't do anything for there anniversary which would had happen near the start of the game or during the summers months which would mean they wasn't together and even after being reunited they still didn't do anything. This relationship is meant to end with MC getting one of them
1000058121.gif
Darkwen... is that you?

But yes, as much as I would love for it to succeed, it feels more and more like the throuple is destined for failure. But I can still cope :whistle::coffee:
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Scopelophila

Darkwen

Forum Fanatic
Nov 10, 2020
5,455
11,701
View attachment 3733046
Darkwen... is that you?

But yes, as much as I would love for it to succeed, it feels more and more like the throuple is destined for failure. But I can still cope :whistle::coffee:
I used to hope for solo ending and a happy throuple ending but at this point I don't think the happy throuple got any shot kind like Mavs being down 0-3
 

Joshy92

Message Maven
Mar 25, 2021
12,290
28,101
she was the one who was not even there to begin with. She suggested the no string attachment in the first place, so her heart never was fully in it anyway.
I think that was because she was scared of getting hurt again and because she was dealing with new feelings she hasn't before remember the MC is the first guy she has ever had feelings for so she is scared.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Better Cock Spock

Geralt From Rivia

Conversation Conqueror
Jun 15, 2022
6,618
42,463
I think it was easier for Maya because she is used to being dissapointed.
One more thing. Maya already lives in hell. Slowly dying mother, bedridden. Father turned into a broken man and a domestic tyrant. A breakup with a guy is still a bad event in life, but less significant than everything that Maya went through. You can look at it this way.
 

ChipLecsap

Conversation Conqueror
Aug 4, 2019
7,263
26,306
I think that was because she was scared of getting hurt again and because she was dealing with new feelings she hasn't before remember the MC is the first guy she has ever had feelings for so she is scared.
or may be she not really care about this anyway, so she can have more time to self pity.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Better Cock Spock

Darkwen

Forum Fanatic
Nov 10, 2020
5,455
11,701
she was the one who was not even there to begin with. She suggested the no string attachment in the first place, so her heart never was fully in it anyway.
Maya was never committed to Josy but now it seems like she is with MC or at least so then she is to Josy. I think part of Josy wish's it could work with Maya but everything Josy wants Maya can't give her and Josy is making it very clear she falling hard for MC where as Maya is more like a ghost to her someone she once loved
 
  • Like
Reactions: Better Cock Spock

Joshy92

Message Maven
Mar 25, 2021
12,290
28,101
or may be she not really care about this anyway, so she can have more time to self pity.
I feel like you're judging her way too harshly. She has suffered so much in her life I mean she has been abused by her piece of shit dad. It's no wonder she developed a shell around herself.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Better Cock Spock

Better Cock Spock

Half Vulcan, Half Simp
Donor
Jul 29, 2017
6,470
21,792
she was the one who was not even there to begin with. She suggested the no string attachment in the first place, so her heart never was fully in it anyway.
I think that was because she was scared of getting hurt again and because she was dealing with new feelings she hasn't before remember the MC is the first guy she has ever had feelings for so she is scared.
"No strings attached" was probably the best move. Both girls cheated on each other, MC went after a girl with a "boyfriend", and on top of that he could potentially be fucking over a dozen different girls. Committing to the throuple right after Episode 4 does not allow for all 3 of them to adjust to the situation, or for Maya and Josy to properly heal, at least for a little bit. It also gives everyone an easy out if the whole thing falls apart, or it should've done if MC didn't drag out the breakup like an asshole.
 

Joshy92

Message Maven
Mar 25, 2021
12,290
28,101
"No strings attached" was probably the best move. Both girls cheated on each other, MC went after a girl with a "boyfriend", and on top of that he could potentially be fucking over a dozen different girls. Committing to the throuple right after Episode 4 does not allow for all 3 of them to adjust to the situation, or for Maya and Josy to properly heal, at least for a little bit. It also gives everyone an easy out if the whole thing falls apart, or it should've done if MC didn't drag out the breakup like an asshole.
I wish there was a way to join the throuple without sleeping with the girls first. That really disappoints me.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Better Cock Spock

Better Cock Spock

Half Vulcan, Half Simp
Donor
Jul 29, 2017
6,470
21,792
I wish there was a way to join the throuple without sleeping with the girls first. That really disappoints me.
That's fair. At least with Maya, she gave the impression she wasn't dating anyone so MC was "in the clear", so to speak. Josy still claimed to have a boyfriend, putting a damper on their first time.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Joshy92

Joshy92

Message Maven
Mar 25, 2021
12,290
28,101
That's fair. At least with Maya, she gave the impression she wasn't dating anyone so MC was "in the clear", so to speak. Josy still claimed to have a boyfriend, putting a damper on their first time.
At first, I thought Josy did have a boyfriend like she said, and I assumed he was a cheating arsehole or something.
I wouldn't have felt bad about sleeping with her if that had of been the case.
 

Darkwen

Forum Fanatic
Nov 10, 2020
5,455
11,701
I feel like you're judging her way too harshly. She has suffered so much in her life I mean she has been abused by her piece of shit dad. It's no wonder she developed a shell around herself.
Maya went through hell but there to much we got to protect her as if she a special needs child yet this the same Maya that put Josy through hell and didn't give a rats ass about Josy feelings just her own hurt feelings
 
  • Like
Reactions: Better Cock Spock

Joshy92

Message Maven
Mar 25, 2021
12,290
28,101
Maya went through hell but there to much we got to protect her as if she a special needs child yet this the same Maya that put Josy through hell and didn't give a rats ass about Josy feelings just her own hurt feelings
She does care about Josy's feelings but she's a young woman coming to terms with her feelings so, she is bound to make some mistakes.

I feel like everyone on here judges Maya more than they do every other girl but how many of them have suffered like she has?
Bella maybe but the rest not anywhere near as much.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Better Cock Spock

ChipLecsap

Conversation Conqueror
Aug 4, 2019
7,263
26,306
I feel like you're judging her way too harshly. She has suffered so much in her life I mean she has been abused by her piece of shit dad. It's no wonder she developed a shell around herself.
No, her Mother is the one who suffering, constantly. and Derek also has it bad, he not even have any kind of self goal in his life, because his life is all about Maya too.
Maya shown her true selfish nature in episode 7.
 

Better Cock Spock

Half Vulcan, Half Simp
Donor
Jul 29, 2017
6,470
21,792
Maya was never committed to Josy but now it seems like she is with MC or at least so then she is to Josy. I think part of Josy wish's it could work with Maya but everything Josy wants Maya can't give her and Josy is making it very clear she falling hard for MC where as Maya is more like a ghost to her someone she once loved
How was Maya never committed to Josy? She was planning to defy her dad and see Josy in secret at B&R, that was the plan, she still wanted to be with her despite Patrick being a piece of shit. If she wasn't committed, it would've been easy to just reject Josy in Episode 4 and be alone, or try and date MC instead.
Maya went through hell but there to much we got to protect her as if she a special needs child yet this the same Maya that put Josy through hell and didn't give a rats ass about Josy feelings just her own hurt feelings
Being separated all summer put a huge strain on them, long-distance relationships are tough. That plus Patrick, it's no wonder they both cheated. Maya admitted that they were on the verge of breaking up, and Josy said that she was giving up and going to just run away. I'd put them equally at fault, and insensitive to each other's feelings.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ModiThorrson
4.80 star(s) 1,600 Votes