I see you're trying to talk with this guy.
Unfortunately, I'm afraid it's a waste of time.
Because what he's talking about is not about off-topic or on-topic. Not at all.
Last year, he told me that I was ruining this thread with my Quinn posting.
I asked him - What about Darkwen, and his Alady posting?
He said - "Just shut up."
So I guess, no, I'm sure that he, Tremonia, and people like them, don't mean off-topic at all.
They just don't like to see opinions different from their own. That's all.
If you want to say something on-topic, talk about something on-topic, just do it.
But no, they'd rather complain about off-topic. It's so convenient.