I am not one of those AVN fans who consider Being a DIK to be the best AVN. There are now a lot of college AVNs and despite BaDIK's outstanding graphics and talent for drama, much of it wears out over time.
But it still deserves five stars. There is hardly an AVN that uses minigames so skilfully, where you learn something and are constantly challenged.
Hardly any AVN manages to stage the plot in such a cinematic way. The tansitions are great. The melodrama is outstanding. I read a critic who criticised BaDIK for its melodrama. But the way I see it, almost all AVNs are melodramas by nature. They live on their emotionality to hide the lack of gameplay.
For a VN BaDIK does have a surprising amount of gameplay though. Be it the puzzle-minigames, free-roaming or the combat sequences. What BaDIK has to offer in the latter area may not be Tekken or Street Fighter, but it's pretty much the best thing in renpay AVNs right now.
BaDIK has a high replayability, because the storyline differs in many places, depending on which LI-path you follow. It's just a question whether you can muster the patience to go through all of this multiple times, since it takes an insane amount of time to play through the whole thing as it is.
But above all, and this is one of the most decisive arguments for me, BaDIK delivers entertainment in series quality and so reliably that an end to this long plot is not in sight. Many AVNs are abandoned prematurely, especially AVNs with high production costs. So far, however, it looks as if we can look forward to many years or seasons of entertainment with BaDIK, at a consistently high and rising level.
In terms of plot, BaDIK is not exactly sophisticated and that might be its biggest weakness. But it is attractive for all those who like to binge-watch 20 seasons of The Simpsons, 15 seasons of Supernatural or 100 seasons of Doctor Who. With BaDIK you are entering a universe that may not end for many years to come. That is an achievement in itself.
Ps. If I'd only be rating episode 9 (without interlude, which I enjoyed) I'd give BaDIK 3 stars instead of 5 as there is no progression, no character development and no meaningful suspense. Also since the end of episode 8 there is increased railroading when it comes to relationships and plot development.