But you also get +1RP for Josy if you call her before going to bed at Bella's, and since you only need 3RP to max out Josy's points, provided you have all her points from eps 1-4, you can do it by dancing with them, going with Maya, then calling Josy.
So, in terms of getting RP, this decision doesn't matter much. It might, however, have an impact later as these choices are recorded by variables, "ep5_fucked_josy" and "ep5_fucked_maya", but there's no way to know which decision, if any, is better in the long run as it seems to be down to personal preference.
may be these varrables, "ep5_fucked_josy" and "ep5_fucked_maya", will comes in to play in EP6.
IF there is a threesome, an actual threesome with MC Josy Maya. then i can see these variables will play a part of it. example:
A )
if you go with Josy , than you will be not able to fuck Maya, during the scene, you get 50% lewd scene maybe. You can Fuck Josy, but Maya will probably do more of a lesbian activity role. you fuck Josy while she lick Maya's pussy , fingering her etc etc.
B)
If you stay with Maya, than Maya will be more participating in the SEX. since she now will have experience with you with a boy. so you could fuck both of them and you get a 100% of the lewd scene.
I think this is a logical assumption, and my theory is may be backed up with the fact, that Josy, does comes in after you and Maya were together, they has this bonus scene , She sitting down, and aks Maya to tell her everything.
with Josy, she just text you telling you that she told Maya about it. yeah Maya also text you , but it's a slightly different conversation.
but i did not like i had to choose, not only for the lewd scene, but both conversation was important.
and yeah the sex of course
Josy, was so adorable how much she wanted impress the MC. and Maya turned out to be straight at pro at blowjob. and it was her fist time, Damn. She liked it, she wanted the dick, she made a great progress. God both scene was hot