lemonfreak

The Freakiest of Lemons
Oct 24, 2018
5,552
10,286
I believe what Leah did in AL and what Peter wanted to do to Melissa are against patreon's T&C... so maybe professor fruity cake will find a way to navigate around it
It's been so long since I played AL that I don't know what you mean but there's no fucking way I'm putting myself through that again so I'll have to assume you're correct.
 

Holy Bacchus

Conversation Conqueror
Dec 13, 2018
7,748
19,532
but MC and Jill aren't family, they didn't grow together etc.
That. Does. Not. Matter.

Legally, any and all familial relationships are considered incest and this includes non-blood related relatives like an adopted sibling, a sister-in-law, a step-Mom, etc. You also don't have to have grown up with the person either; for example, if a guy's Dad got remarried to a woman who has a daughter, that would make his son and her daughter legally considered to be siblings even though they have no blood relation and haven't known each other until their parents met, and if they have sex then that is still incest under the law.

Therefore, Patreon takes a harsh stance against any form of incest (when they find out about it), no matter how diuted it might seem.
 

Alfagrem

Member
Aug 23, 2017
171
293
The biggest thing that bothers me about Maya is the sheer amount of winking she does.
That. Does. Not. Matter.

Legally, any and all familial relationships are considered incest and this includes non-blood related relatives like an adopted sibling, a sister-in-law, a step-Mom, etc. You also don't have to have grown up with the person either; for example, if a guy's Dad got remarried to a woman who has a daughter, that would make his son and her daughter legally considered to be siblings even though they have no blood relation and haven't known each other until their parents met, and if they have sex then that is still incest under the law.

Therefore, Patreon takes a harsh stance against any form of incest (when they find out about it), no matter how diuted it might seem.
What if it's a time travel game and the person is your great-great-great-great-great grandaughter?
 

lemonfreak

The Freakiest of Lemons
Oct 24, 2018
5,552
10,286
The biggest thing that bothers me about Maya is the sheer amount of winking she does.


What if it's a time travel game and the person is your great-great-great-great-great grandaughter?
As long as it's never revealed to us, the players, that time travel is involved it shouldn't be a problem ;)
 

Qmil679

Q / Motherlover
Donor
Mar 13, 2019
5,075
13,726
Are there consequences when we tell Quinn we had sex with Camila on the first order?
I never chose the option to let Quinn find out because I didn't want to cause Camila problems, because I like her.
 

always86

Active Member
Mar 19, 2020
875
2,259
That. Does. Not. Matter.

Legally, any and all familial relationships are considered incest and this includes non-blood related relatives like an adopted sibling, a sister-in-law, a step-Mom, etc. You also don't have to have grown up with the person either; for example, if a guy's Dad got remarried to a woman who has a daughter, that would make his son and her daughter legally considered to be siblings even though they have no blood relation and haven't known each other until their parents met, and if they have sex then that is still incest under the law.

Therefore, Patreon takes a harsh stance against any form of incest (when they find out about it), no matter how diuted it might seem.
I'm not actually sure that is true, though it may depend where you are from. Patreon seem to let people get away with the 'adopted' brother and sister angle quite regularly. It's also the way most porn companies use to skirt the law. If Jill was adopted in to the family it would not be incest, not by any reasonable measure. I don't even think it would be immoral. If she and MC have no blood relationship and no known familial ties up to this point in thier life then I don't think that is an issue.

I don't care one way or the other. I'm just saying if it happens it's not shocking to me. I think the Burgmeister path is actually more likely.

On another note not sure anyone has pointed this out.

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

These could be Quinn's feet as the next shot turns to the right and then the following one Quinn is standing infront of Riona. Other possibilities;

Police monitoring them in the van
Somone else watching them
 

lemonfreak

The Freakiest of Lemons
Oct 24, 2018
5,552
10,286
I'm not actually sure that is true, though it may depend where you are from. Patreon seem to let people get away with the 'adopted' brother and sister angle quite regularly. It's also the way most porn companies use to skirt the law. If Jill was adopted in to the family it would not be incest, not by any reasonable measure. I don't even think it would be immoral. If she and MC have no blood relationship and no known familial ties up to this point in thier life then I don't think that is an issue.

I don't care one way or the other. I'm just saying if it happens it's not shocking to me. I think the Burgmeister path is actually more likely.

On another note not sure anyone has pointed this out.

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

These could be Quinn's feet as the next shot turns to the right and then the following one Quinn is standing infront of Riona. Other possibilities;

Police monitoring them in the van
Somone else watching them
Yes, there are games with incest that slip through, that's not because Patreon endorses that content but because they don't know about it; they rely on people reporting violations since they lack the manpower to check every single creator. It's a bug, not a feature.
 

always86

Active Member
Mar 19, 2020
875
2,259
Yes, there are games with incest that slip through, that's not because Patreon endorses that content but because they don't know about it; they rely on people reporting violations since they lack the manpower to check every single creator. It's a bug, not a feature.
Actually...
Patreon Rules.PNG

As per the bottom line, context can create exceptions. I'm not saying they would let something like Big Brother skirt the rules, however an Unknown Aunt/ Nephew relationship as per Game of Thrones would be explicitly allowed.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dashxp4k

felicemastronzo

Devoted Member
May 17, 2020
11,551
22,429
Actually...
View attachment 728090

As per the bottom line, context can create exceptions. I'm not saying they would let something like Big Brother skirt the rules, however an Unknown Aunt/ Nephew relationship as per Game of Thrones would be explicitly allowed.
I know very little Patreon and its rules. but here the incest question is upstream.

"Being a DIK" is clearly a story that would not gain anything from the presence of incest. It is a teen drama set in a school, what would incest add?

if one of the LIs was discovered to be a relative of MC, never having known each other, never lived together, there would be no moral but only social remorse.
therefore the "surprise" relative of MC would either give up any romantic relationship with him, or decide to go on

no advantage neither in terms of history nor in terms of sexual tension, of kinky. like pineapple on a pizza
 

TundraLupus

Well-Known Member
Apr 8, 2020
1,768
2,068
Actually...
View attachment 728090

As per the bottom line, context can create exceptions. I'm not saying they would let something like Big Brother skirt the rules, however an Unknown Aunt/ Nephew relationship as per Game of Thrones would be explicitly allowed.
Yeah, they shouldn't have used GoT because, well, the Lannisters, also, their prejudice scaped a little on that text, putting necrophilia and rape in the same context as incest, sheesh.
 

always86

Active Member
Mar 19, 2020
875
2,259
I know very little Patreon and its rules. but here the incest question is upstream.

"Being a DIK" is clearly a story that would not gain anything from the presence of incest. It is a teen drama set in a school, what would incest add?

if one of the LIs was discovered to be a relative of MC, never having known each other, never lived together, there would be no moral but only social remorse.
therefore the "surprise" relative of MC would either give up any romantic relationship with him, or decide to go on

no advantage neither in terms of history nor in terms of sexual tension, of kinky. like pineapple on a pizza
The story value in this instance would be in the morality and the heart break. If DPC spends hours establishing that these two people have fallen in love then reveals they are related it creates a massive amount of drama and conflict. I'm not saying it will happen, I just don't think the idea should be written off. In Got the value is dramatic conflict and the emotional repacussions. It's two young people around the same age in love, but as it turns out who are related. The specific example I was actually thinking of was Jon and Dany as Aunt/ Nephew, not Cersei and Jamie, though that's another example in that show.
 
  • Angry
Reactions: lemonfreak

Darkdevil66

Well-Known Member
Apr 16, 2020
1,666
40,149
Are there consequences when we tell Quinn we had sex with Camila on the first order?
I never chose the option to let Quinn find out because I didn't want to cause Camila problems, because I like her.
If you do, Quinn briefly scolds Camila in the pool (ep3). Except that no consequence.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Qmil679

Meushi

Well-Known Member
Aug 4, 2017
1,146
12,748
If DPC spends hours establishing that these two people have fallen in love then reveals they are related it creates a massive amount of drama and conflict. I'm not saying it will happen, I just don't think the idea should be written off.
There is no incest in BaDIK, now or in the future:
  • DPC doesn't do incest.
  • Patreon doesn't allow incest. Yes we're aware of the context clause, not applicable for a porn game.
  • The thread has no incest tag.
Regardless of whatever arcane conjecture you're proposing to justify incest in BaDIK, the fact remains there's none.

Brought to you by the coalition against flogging dead horses.
 

Kailadan

New Member
Mar 25, 2020
12
22
I highly doubt that we're going to suddenly find out that the MC is related to any other characters in the game, personally. Now, I COULD see finding out that his mother came from one of the families that founded the school that Isabella went to. I don't see him getting an inheritance, though, even if offered. The guy loves the heck out of his dad, but his mom's parents essentially disowned her for being with him. That alone would probably leave him conflicted if the grandparents suddenly wanted to meet him or give him anything, assuming that the letter has anything to do with them at all.

I do kinda expect the MC to fall into some money due to his mother somehow, though. Maybe she had some stuff in her father's and her name that got sold, and the MC was awarded some of the profit due to her being dead. If he does get a bit of money, I wouldn't be surprised if we have to make a difficult choice on what to do with it. The MC isn't the type of person to keep it himself, so maybe you have to make a choice on who gets it, like other people have suggested.

The choices would probably align with the possible relationships, like the tuition for Maya so that her and Josy (and you if you chose it), allowing them to escape Maya's father and just be happy without having to hide it. You could give it to Sage to get the HOT's out of the mess that Quinn has created, because I'm 100% certain that Sage actually knows what Quinn's up to; hence the party in episode 5 being for Quinn, NOT the HOT's. For Jill, maybe it would have something to do with the project that gets mentioned a few times that she's trying to set up. Perhaps something that she can't get herself for whatever reason. Isabella would probably have something to do about her missing husband. I'm sure fixing the DIK mansion and helping your dad would be in there, too.

Or, I'm just pulling things out of my behind (100% likely) and just like speculating a little too much.
 
4.80 star(s) 1,553 Votes