It isn't even in my top 10, it's too early for that. Yes, it is the most popular game in the site because it's been hyped by everyone, but as someone who values characters and their development way more than anything else, I don't think is that good. If i had to rate it, I would give it a 7/10. With how early we are in the game's life, it would be dishonest for me to give it more. And I'll leave it at that because I don't like to be negative in a game's thread (unless the name of the dev starts with S and rhymes with Slonique).
I have to disagree,it is precisely characters or 1 specific character that makes it really good.You can have the highest quality renders and the most smooth gameplay and the most beautiful models but without anyone to connect with,you`ll end up satysfying only Jill fans(HA! jk)
- you`ll end up with nice looking,somewhat enjoyable,forgetable game.
I genuinly don`t remember being this invested in a fictional character...perhaps Triss Merigold and I`m talking books,years before the Witcher 3 or even 2 came out.
Yes, Phillys new game is very very good also, but not better than BaDIK IMO.
That`s subjective
COBD is a straight forward VN - which is what some players want.
DIK is very ambitious,in a sens that it incorporates couple of different mechanics and makes it work but PinkCake,like every very creative person needs a proof reader,someone who will tell him:"that`s a bad idea,dont do it". Nontheless,just like AL it certainly transcends above a porn game.
I'm a Patron of DrPink and Philly too and i respect both their works ; But to make a comparison between their respective games it's like to compares apples with pears.
And i really don't like when it's create like a stadium cheering between two different factions without any kind of reason.
Let's just enjoy these two developers completely different from each other ( for the writing and the kind od plot ) , that they raise up so much the bar quality and forget this kind of unnecessary ranking ....
No,it`s fine,you can be a fan of Star Trek and Star Wars and compare them without taking away anything from neither,some will like sci-fi aspect of ST more while others will like space opera and hero`s journey aspects of SW more.