I don't really know the D&D rules to precisely differentiate, but...
Jill:
Agree,
Lawful Good to the point of puking!
M&J:
Too boring to debate, so I'll say
Neutral Good is accurate.
Sage:
I don't know about her being all that Chaotic. I know we'd all like to think of her as the "bad" girl who doesn't play by the rules. But what rules is she actually breaking? No I think she's a lawful character. She's the head of the HOTs and she treats them right. She takes all her responsibilities seriously and apart from holding hands under a blanket once in a while, she's not really rebelling. Her big departure from the rule of law is letting the mc stay at the HOTs for a bit (if you went down that path). But even so, she was straight up with the other HOTs about the situation. So no Chaos there to be found.
I'm gonna go with
Lawful Good even though it seems surprising on the surface.
Bella:
Definitely not lawful. Sleeping with students, staying over night at the DIKs. This woman is Chaotic. But she's so conflicted, she's not just all about herself. So I'm gonna go with
Chaotic Neutral. Now if we find her dead husband's body behind door number 3, this may need to be revised...
MC:
He may have started off as True Neutral before I got into his psyche, but he's
Chaotic Evil at this point. Doesn't follow the rules (breaking and entering, attacking people, fucking everything that moves, cheating on innocent girls that care for him) and it's all done for his own selfish gratification.
Derek:
I don't think he's Neutral. He does things for the right reasons. I'm gonna go with
Chaotic Good. He fucked a granny for the team. I think that's all that needs to be said.
Tybalt:
I wouldn't have thought Tybalt is Lawful:
- He lies (Fake tan, fake watch, fake accent - yellow teeth are real though, fake stories to Jill)
- He blackmails (blackmail isn't inherently evil, you may blackmail someone in an attempt to save the world)
- He spies on people (peeping on Jill when she's getting a real tan)
So with just those traits above, I'd say he's outright chaotic (but tries to give the fake impression that he is lawful to have the higher moral ground).
And his motivation for all of these chaotic acts is far from altruistic. Blackmailing a girl in order to sleep with her, that's down right evil (it sure as hell isn't good, nor is it neutral).
So there you have it, Tybalt is a
Chaotic Evil character, it's just that he sucks so much he's not much of a threat (unless you're a stupid gullible girl - but we all know that's not Jill!)
Quinn:
Everything she does is for her own gratification, and she couldn't give a fuck about the rules. She's a drug dealer for fuck's sake who's pimping out college girls and lies to the HOTs about her revenue raising being for them when it's really just for herself.
Chaotic Evil and I love her for it!
Dawe:
He's just stupid. He did attack the MC unprovoked, so that pushes him into the Chaotic realm, but it was because he thought he was standing up for his bros. I guess orchestrating the throwing of dildos through someone else's property consolidates that. But he's not all about himself. I don't know of any Evil actions that he's taken. I'd go as far as to say he's
Chaotic Neutral.
