Holy Bacchus
Conversation Conqueror
- Dec 13, 2018
- 7,748
- 19,542
I agree that him being in the room represents a new danger to Maya and Josy given that he can enter their room unannounced at any time, but I disagree very strongly that this danger is somehow "cancelled" by them not having a full confrontation where he finds out about Josy.I try to explain myself better.
seeing Maya's father waiting for the two girls in the room represents a great danger, an unexpected danger in that form, one thing was the pressure he could put on Maya, one thing is the danger of his physical and unexpected presence at that moment.
if the girls avoid him, realizing however that he can enter their room, they completely cancel this danger. the pressure remains, but that was there before.
Josy should have lived elsewhere before, they talked about it as soon as she gets to BR and then they ignore it for a week.
therefore all the new dynamics, if any, of Maya and Josy moving away we could have lived without the need for a night visit from Maya's father.
in this sense the cliffhanger is completely canceled, it would not bring any effect that should not have arrived the same. this is the definition of useless
If he's not in the room when they get back, then the danger is ever-present but unknown to them which creates tension and suspense for the players/audience not knowing when he'll strike again. It's a like a show ending with the psycho stalker in the house as the protag enters, then in the next episode nothing happens because the stalker had time to flee before they fully opened the door. We as the audience are now on edge not knowing when they'll return or what they'll do.
As for Josy being able to remain undiscovered, it keeps the pressure of Maya's Dad on their relationship because just when they thought they were safe to spend time together, they now have to keep their distance as much as possible, not knowing when her Dad might show up again and this slight separation coupled with Maya still not standing up to her Dad in defense of their relationship can put the kind of strain on their relationship that could result in possible break-up and solo paths.
So neither of these would be "useless" just because the cliffhanger doesn't resolve itself in all 3 entering the room and having a confrontation with Maya's Dad where he officially cuts her off. They're actually more useful in many ways at deepening the drama of their situation and opening up new issues and difficulties for them to tackle.