felicemastronzo

Devoted Member
May 17, 2020
11,551
22,430
I take your word for it :). Though I'm skeptical, considering there is really not much of difference whether you only chase Jill or not , so I'm not sure if it's actually a beautiful love story.:unsure: one thing however is sure, it is definitely "out of the place" , compared to the rest of the game. its like saying for example , in a horror movie, beneath all the killing , there is a nice romantic story :ROFLMAO:. . It's like Jill is from a different game , and her only purpose for this game is to connect us to the Preps.:unsure:

and I must Say, if Maya would not be in the picture, the Josy love story would be without question the best in the game, for me at least :ROFLMAO:. May be Bella would be a strong second, but age gap is age gap. The summer fling you think you will never see again , but then show up, when you least expecting , and reconciliation with her, while you life changed is pretty fun , even with maya in the picture, but would be beter wiht out her. :ROFLMAO:.

I Indeed felt more the MC and Jay relationship in this episode, then with Jill during any time except the first Tennis date. They are looked like an actual college couple during this episode, expecillay with the hand holding at the end, in the Gym . :love:.

But I won't deny that I'm also Bias Toward Josy at this moment:ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO:
Until the fifth chapter I was convinced that the solo routes didn't make sense at all, both because it was too early (and this is still true now) and because in the story it was "normal" for Mc to have different relationships and experiences.

but I'm changing my mind and not because the two previous reasons are no longer valid, but the story makes much more sense if MC behaves in a 'faithful' way.

the whole rebound boyfriend thing with Sage only makes sense if Sage is "his great love", otherwise why would he give up sex with her? when apparently being her fuck buddy has worked out well for him so far

Jill's story even more than the others, an MC who is interested in other girls would have neither the time nor the desire to keep up with the little princess' dreams, he would choose 99 times out of 100 to "not fight for her" (what a strange scene...). hers is a particular story (which i can also accept) that lived together with the others becomes quite indigestible
 

Ezes

Member
Mar 12, 2021
291
1,152
Sage is chatting with Josy at the Hot's party. Also about the problems Josy and Tommy have. Sage will surely give Josy some advice to solve the problem.

At the party, Josy also tells the MC that she only told Sage how they met.

When Sage and Maya talk at the end, Maya probably told Sage everything. This conversation is after the Tommy scene with the legs. Sage just says "Wow...." in amazement. For this "wow" I think DPC put two options in the game.
but there were 2 in tommy's bed, one black and one white, josy is not black if he is not tanned and maya only with someone like that I do not think it will happen, regarding maya and sage she will have told him all the problems mc Josy and Maya passed. I still believe that tommy did a threesome with the roses in revenge that heather found out about the hoax
 

Picc4h

Newbie
Aug 13, 2018
36
120
Been lurking this thread since it had about 4k pages and to this day I can't believe the troy-chad theory turned out to be true, fuck.
But anyway, after all this time and finishing ep7 thrice I felt like sharing an opinion or two of mine, probably an unpopular ones but fuck it: Either Quinn or Riona would have made a better major girl in Jill's place, also I still don't understand why she's the only one MC can't reject early, unlike every other girl at some point (both major and minor). Really hope DPC will give us the chance in either ep 8 or 9.
Also the way Jill is put in the story sometimes is somehow forced, both these opinions makes me think she's DPC's favourite or something, but idk... that might just be me.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
 
Last edited:

Ottoeight

Forum Fanatic
Mar 13, 2021
5,178
9,163
I wonder why so many people writing in this thread are talking about a Quinn route. There is no such a thing.

MC's love interests are the girls you see at the end of each chapter. Everybody else is just a bangable side character.

Quinn? she's not even a bangable side girl: she is the hero's main antagonist.

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Moreover, I wonder why so many people did forget that MC's first and main love interests at the beginning of the story are Maya and Josy. Sage, Jill and Bella are their placeholders, after all.

Anyway, I wouldn't be surprised if we find out that MC's mom
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
.
 

Ottoeight

Forum Fanatic
Mar 13, 2021
5,178
9,163
Been lurking this thread since it had about 4k pages and to this day I can't believe the troy-chad theory turned out to be true, fuck.
But anyway, after all this time and finishing ep7 thrice I felt like sharing an opinion or two of mine, probably an unpopular ones but fuck it: Either Quinn or Riona would have made a better major girl in Jill's place, also I still don't understand why she's the only one MC can't reject early, unlike every other girl at some point (both major and minor). Really hope DPC will give us the chance in either ep 8 or 9.
Also the way she's put in the story sometimes is somehow forced, both these opinions makes me think she's DPC's favourite or something, but idk... that might just be me.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
Every story needs a VILLAIN. Quinn is this story's villain.

I guess some people aren't able to deal with it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SSJGOD and `Ray`

Canto Forte

Post Pro
Jul 10, 2017
21,616
26,645
Josy is the very 1st and only real connection true love story where MC genuinely does
a stellar job and she is in over her head invested in cuddling his feelings and caressing his ego. Maya comes in with the lovable suffering bro connection, so the 3some is complete.

Been lurking this thread since it had about 4k pages and to this day I can't believe the troy-chad theory turned out to be true, fuck.
But anyway, after all this time and finishing ep7 thrice I felt like sharing an opinion or two of mine, probably an unpopular ones but fuck it: Either Quinn or Riona would have made a better major girl in Jill's place, also I still don't understand why she's the only one MC can't reject early, unlike every other girl at some point (both major and minor). Really hope DPC will give us the chance in either ep 8 or 9.
Also the way she's put in the story sometimes is somehow forced, both these opinions makes me think she's DPC's favourite or something, but idk... that might just be me.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
MC be fumbling into a lot of babes and daring his way into the life on campus.
All the early interactions are there to steal the reel, so deeper connections are
kind of lef field outta nowhere compared to the rollercoasters Josy and Maya are.

I wonder why so many people writing in this thread are talking about a Quinn route. There is no such a thing.

MC's love interests are the girls you see at the end of each chapter. Everybody else is just a bangable side character.

Quinn? she's not even a bangable side girl: she is the hero's main antagonist.

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Moreover, I wonder why so many people did forget that MC's first and main love interests at the beginning of the story are Maya and Josy. Sage, Jill and Bella are their placeholders, after all.

Anyway, I wouldn't be surprised if we find out that MC's mom
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
.
Keep your friends close and your enemies closer.
Nuff said.
 

D2M3

Member
Jan 20, 2018
345
909
Anyway, I wouldn't be surprised if we find out that MC's mom
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
.
I mean, I can see this happening, and it'd be an okay twist.... Just the... That option presents little to no storytelling result.

Like, Rusty is already on super good terms with MC. There is no friction or drama that can result from this. And that alone.... kinda makes the whole twist, useless. And DPC loves him some good D.R.A.M.A.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ename144

Picc4h

Newbie
Aug 13, 2018
36
120
Every story needs a VILLAIN. Quinn is this story's villain.

I guess some people aren't able to deal with it.
Ehm... ok? See her however you see it fit for yourself, I totally get it and respect it but... What has this to do with my opinions on Jill and why she can't be rejected yet unlike every single girl?
 

Daxos89

Newbie
Jan 12, 2019
54
66
I mean, I can see this happening, and it'd be an okay twist.... Just the... That option presents little to no storytelling result.

Like, Rusty is already on super good terms with MC. There is no friction or drama that can result from this. And that alone.... kinda makes the whole twist, useless. And DPC loves him some good D.R.A.M.A.
I would conaider this bad writing not drama. What kind of person doea not know their own mother's full name...
 
  • Like
Reactions: isotope

Warscared

Well-Known Member
Jan 26, 2021
1,808
11,240
The VC will be very difficult for Maya fans.
Remember that Jill was added to BaD as LI by DPC later in the creation of his story? (The HB you posted in the thread)
The reason for that will have been that Patreon tightened its incest rule and DPC probably had to rebuild its story because of that. I think the first conception of the story was gelpant with step sibling sex. But it messed up his story and he had to write a new branch. That's why there is Zoey.

TO THE TOPIC.

The MC has the opportunity in EP7 to tell Heather about Tommy's betrayal and for that the MC is owed by Heather. This will influence the decision for the presidency of the HOT's. Sage will win and Heather will become VP. However, this decision shows 2 pairs of legs in Tommy's room.

If the MC doesn't tell Heather, there will be a tie in the presidential election and the girls will give the MC the deciding vote. There are only one pair of legs on Tommy's bed. If the MC chooses Quinn, all will be well with Josy, but not so well for Maya. If the MC chooses Sage, everything can be good for Josy and Maya. But Heather will not be VP. I think VP will be one of the 3 (Josy, Maya, Lily).

But the Heather decision has its consequences for Maya. I am not a foot fetishist. But I have spent the last 2 days comparing the girls feet and toes because it just gave me no peace. I think that will be the 2 pairs of legs of Zoey and Maya. Why?

Josy and Tommy want to bury their hatchet. Tommy will be the one sabotaging Josy and Maya's relationship. But when the MC tells Heather about Tommy's infidelity, Josy will probably have to convince Maya that Tommy will only agree if she has sex with him. Maya will agree out of love (whether just Josy or Josy/MC). Now it comes quite thick for the entspiel. If Maya has had sex with the MC, she might get pregnant. (Remember Neil and his condom warning) If she has now also had sex with Tommy, she could get pregnant.

If the MC doesn't tell Heather it will be Zoey.
But no matter what decision is made regarding Heather, there will be a confrontation with Tommy. Either because of Maya or because he finds out that Zoey and the MC had something together.

Now if the MC chooses Sage, Quinn will take revenge on the MC and try to sabotage his relationship (whether throuple or solo routes) by bringing the cumpetition into play. If the MC gets the Sage and Chad thing right, Sarah and Mel will help the MC, Josy and Maya.

And now I come to Jill.
DPC might not be able to finish the throuple properly without incest. Now when the picture of MC Cock appears on the presentation, there is the conversation of Josy and Jill. Josy will encourage Jill because she realized that the MC is a DIK just like Tommy. She is preparing to break up with the MC, but still wants to give him a chance with Jill. Josy will then stay with Maya because she is responsible for all of this and with Zoey Josy shouldn't have a problem either because it all started years ago with Josy, Zoey and Tommy.

Whether it's Throuple or Solo routes, the MC will eventually have to face the question of being the father of Maya's child. (Reminds me of the story of MC family tree).

Maybe I'm right or maybe I'm wrong. It is meant to be food for thought for you guys.
Dude it can not be Maya! that would be very heavy NTR route! not to mention that except for the MC Maya does not feel comfortable with Boys! that means she can only sleep with a dude on the MC route because that is when she gets confortable! even if your projections where to be right!

Maya would leave immediately after the sex was done because she would feel disgusted with herself! that girl stayed over...

DPC is writing the game not your average porn game incest NTR writer!

Check the skin tones one of them is Heather the other is clearly a well tanned brunette! my gold is on Becky! heather always goes over to Tommy most nights as it seems from what we have seen so far! so if you told Heather she decides to fight for her man and give him a taste of what he is risking loosing if he keeps his hiding shit from her!

she does not demand a monotonous sorry i mean monogamous relationship! she demands honesty!

So the threesome we imagine can only be from someone she asked and would accept! Josy would be one hell of a twist but as the same for any Main LI + Quinn it would mean massive NTR for such a small decision! So who can Heather turn that is a brunette and is at the party? who would want heather backing enough to accept such a proposal?

Lilly for suport from heather? (light NTR here and i doubt DPC would go there)
Josy for tommy and heather acceptance (heavy heavy NTR)
Becky to keep being one of the cool bitches, Heather is influential so Becky would do it to stay on her good side and get brownie points with the DIk VP! you can even imagine she got turned on by the MC and was hoping that after the BJ she looked for him to go home with him but he had already left with Josy so heather proposal was her plan B!

also If you take Josy back to the mansion how stupid would it be for Maya to also be there? risk being seen by the MC and Derek and risk loosing 2 of the only 3 people she as left in her life?

as for Josy she is magical but i doubt she can be in 2 places at the same time... except in the game and in ChipLecsap heart!
 
Last edited:

HenzoStar

Member
Apr 24, 2020
126
144
The MC will be able to ride off into the sunset with Quinn, I'm relatively sure of that. But the consequence will be that the MC will lose all LI's and will not find his maternal family. The MC will end up like Vinny. If you can live with it, that's okay with me.(y)
Back to my last paragraph, there is no guarantee we would get that ending oh no no, have u forgotten the point of this discussion? it is to cure Quinn on her toxic behaviour, so not only we will be fine if we suceed we will also get +1 achievement in our life. Let that sink in.
 

Tadpol

Member
Mar 22, 2021
362
546
Until the fifth chapter I was convinced that the solo routes didn't make sense at all, both because it was too early (and this is still true now) and because in the story it was "normal" for Mc to have different relationships and experiences.

but I'm changing my mind and not because the two previous reasons are no longer valid, but the story makes much more sense if MC behaves in a 'faithful' way.

the whole rebound boyfriend thing with Sage only makes sense if Sage is "his great love", otherwise why would he give up sex with her? when apparently being her fuck buddy has worked out well for him so far

Jill's story even more than the others, an MC who is interested in other girls would have neither the time nor the desire to keep up with the little princess' dreams, he would choose 99 times out of 100 to "not fight for her" (what a strange scene...). hers is a particular story (which i can also accept) that lived together with the others becomes quite indigestible
Totally agree.

We read the MC's thoughts very often. At the end of the episodes, we have the summary of our relationship with the 5 LI, and these are the thoughts of the MC and not a factual summary.

We must not forget that history is written without us. We are not 100% the writers of the story.

It's a bit confusing. Because we still have decision-making power, but not all the time. I compare it to being on a train, you don't drive it, but sometimes you can choose to operate the switches to go left or right.
 
4.80 star(s) 1,553 Votes