I assume your done with the latest stuff but just in case or for others who haven't
Personally I dislike Maya and wont pursue her. (If she wasn't so heavily forced on us I might like her more)
Josy is probably my 3rd, She kind of flirts the line of DIK and CHIK playstyles which I like.
Jill, True she might be the most girlfriend material like, But with School and Family I could see some problems arising for the MC
Bella obviously has the issues of her Marriage and the full story of that but she is probably my fav LI currently
Sage, definitely my 2nd fav. She seems pretty good GF material for me, President of a Sorority, Bella was impressed by her school prep and future plans. Plus she is feisty and I love it