Controversial maybe, but I would turn down Arieth if she offered my MC a go. She is just too dumb for me, and the way that MC refuses to wear a rainjacket, it would not surprise me if there is an easter egg ending with pregnant Arieth...
As for Jill, I generally agree with
9xr-s69 . I like her, she seems nice, I am not sure why so many are upset that she prefers to save herself. But as for doing a Jill path - I think it will be a good playthrough once episode 20 comes out
My main playthrough has a DiK affinity not permanently locked, I am hooking up with everyone still, and I am going with M+J and Jill, Bella, Sage. Cathy path closed on the drive home, and somehow missed Quinn on my main playthrough. But as I said, still all LIs. I think the dick pic was the first real problem with a potential Jill path my playthrough hit at EP7. So it is not as if she as a character just writes MC off.