I love Nicole, too, but I highly doubt the "has no drama" part. She's a single mom in her 30s working as a stripper. She must have drama in her life. All we can say is that Tremolo simply has no clue because he doesn't know her at all.
I love all the women in this game, but have to agree that if this were real life, Josy would be the best candidate, followed by Maya. With Maya you even get an awesome brother-in-law with Derek. The biggest risk is that at some point she realizes her thing for Tremolo was a fleeting infatuation and she's actually a full-on lesbian. Josy is the same age, cute, loves sex, and sweet. What's not to love?
Jill and Sage are both awesome, but Tremolo is just starting his college career and they are graduating, so the timing is bad. Quinn is sexy af but she is trouble with a capital T. Camila might be cool, but we really don't know anything about her other than she has a big ass and turns tricks (works as a prostitute, for people who don't know that phrase). Riona, Sarah, Melanie, Lily, and most of the other women are hot, but seem only interested in Tremolo's cock. Not complaining, but a relationship is (for better or worse) about more than sex.