felicemastronzo
Message Maven
- May 17, 2020
- 12,225
- 23,216
- 978
I believe that 99% we will never know who was behind those photos (there is no reason to consider it blackmail)Theres a bunch of things that doesn't add up in this world but lets go with it.
Only got two ironclad premises in all this, first Chad doesn't want to lose his beard as he is very angry and physical about it, secondly, the blackmail having homosexual Chad&Troy evidence in it due to his shock then fear and anger, then fearfull crying sadness. It was an overblown reaction unless that was what was in it.
If Mel and Sarah is behind it then Chad doesnt know that they know. No way in hell.
So lets start at the beginning and you want to break a couple up. Easy, you don't start with blackmail, you do the obvious thing first and when that doesn't work you THEN escalate to blackmail. The obvious thing we have seen is the planting the panties among his stuff that Sage finds. Should have been an open and shut case right there, that she would dump his ass. But she doesn't, some people are too angry/forgiving and Sage just so happens to be one of them or whatever.
So they resort to blackmail. I just cant make it mesh with the rest of the blackmail material that happens to fuck with other people. Plus they seem way too chummy with Chad later on (the Hots Party) and he should be real suspicious if they KNEW. Random new people just don't have that much material if that is what they are talking about. This fails too and they begin to crack. If they were the blackmailers only the one thing about Chad and Troy should have been in it.
The extra blackmail and the chumminess at the party as well as concern for Sage and then the cracking really mess with stuff. If they are close enough with Chad from the beginning to know then it couldn't be them with the panties first and then the blackmail because Chad would have suspected them at once.
Its just a fucking mess with too many angles imo whichever way you look at it. I get a headache just trying to put together it all. Theres tiny caveats that sets you down a new path depending who knows what and is behind which part. I don't like any of it. Its shoddy work unless something very compelling stuff is going to be revealed. Or we are misunderstanding what have been shown and lead down a false path.
I really hate this all to be honest. It all feels off and convoluted. I really want clarity in all of this. I feel we are missing something significant. All the extra blackmail stuff is just so OFF as well as the chumminess and then the clear concern for peoples feelings.
the function of that scene has been completely exhausted, no one is looking for the culprit, no one is talking about it anymore.
among the many mysteries that are pending and will be added even in the ninth chapter why should DPC waste time to close this one?
maybe we will find out why Melanie's coivnolation, if she was involved then maybe it would close the case, otherwise it will remain unsolved