KАRАMBA

Engaged Member
Jan 6, 2021
3,716
11,125
688
Welcome to the thread.

1. As long as those shifts on characters' personality/behaviour do not feel totally out of character and the narrative provides solid background for them to happen, it's OK for me.

2. I am conflicted with this. I sometimes hate the waiting, literally. But on the other hand, feeling the thrill of anticipation while waiting for a new episode can be a nice sensation. And it provides a better ground for the flourishing of communities like this one.
So you call what 's happening here flourishing ?
Flourishing...
rpOSrui.gif
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Jumbi

Darkwen

Devoted Member
Nov 10, 2020
8,293
14,501
814
Outside the throuple their relationship is flimsy. The contrast is shown in EP9 beginning. In throuple they quickly settled the conflict and dispute over the price of the costumes, while without the MC, this dispute dragged on for a week and they continued to argue even upon arrival at the party. All this makes Josy doubt in her choice. Although she tried to move on and said that she no longer wants to cheat and lie. But it also wasn't worked.

View attachment 2776614

Code:
js "Thank you for the shirt."
mc "Don't mention it. It would have been weird to sleep in that dress."
js "And weirder to sleep without it, huh?"
mc "..."
js "..."
js "Maybe I should take the couch?"
mc "I thought you were comfortable?"
js "I am, but you know why... Because of us."
mc "I can take the couch, no problem."
js "I'm not a cheater. I mean, I did it, but I don't want to be that anymore."
mc "I don't want that either."
js "I love Maya..."
js "But I thought these feelings I have for you would fade."
js "Yet, every time I see your face... I..."
mc "Shh..."
js "I still have your sweater, you know?"
mc "Did you bring it here?"
js "It was the first thing I grabbed when I packed my suitcase."
js "I...don't know what I'm saying right now. Tell me to shut up."
if affinity == "DIK":
mc "Ok... Uh... Shut up."
elif True:
mc "I'll never tell you that. I've always liked listening to you talk."
js "Haha..."
js "Good night..."
It will depend on how her potential solo route would open. If it will start from cheating on Maya then it probably will be the path of drama. If she will try to talk to Maya first, then maybe things will be less dramatic. The same for Maya solo path, but... it, probably, will always lead to a significant drama. Because Josy is still have all that feelings at first, and secondly bc of her fear of loneliness.

I don't think that Josy has a high tendency to cheat. She did it before (as well as Maya) because she was sure that her relationship is over. But she can't help herself and supress her feelings and pretend that all is fine. In throuple she doesn't need to pick anyone, bc she can get both people she love. In couple with Maya, with all that fights and arguing and when MC is not near them to help and support it starts to bother her and that's why she doubt in her choice.

As MC we have a choice now. To help their relationship to survive or to stand aside. I will not believe if DPC will not force us to make a cruel choice and betray one of them and MC's own promise which he give to himself and also told to Derek. That he is not the guy, who ruin relationships and that she won't hurt them.

In overall, cheating (or temptation) or whatever else points with Josy means and made this way because of that choice in EP5. It's an unique feature in the game. If player plan to pursue solo Josy or Maya then he'd be better on "others" road. Otherwise this is mental cheating and direct doubt in choice previously made regarding the MG LI.

I was surprised that DPC left the option to tell Josy that MC is think about her a bit or all the time in case, when in EP5 we made a choice where MC doesn't have any feelings for her anymore, or he have feelings for Maya...
I tend to think a solo path will open within the throuple, I question if it will happen on others path at this point. The most likely path feel like in the throuple it's already setup with how mc spends his time. Balance will keep it going spending more time with one of the girls opens solo with that girl. The fan walk though indicates something is coming with Josy and Maya so choices are going to matter a lot but that's just what I think
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kpyna and daxil94

daxil94

Member
Aug 27, 2019
105
164
134
I tend to think a solo path will open within the throuple, I question if it will happen on others path at this point. The most likely path feel like in the throuple it's already setup with how mc spends his time. Balance will keep it going spending more time with one of the girls opens solo with that girl. The fan walk though indicates something is coming with Josy and Maya so choices are going to matter a lot but that's just what I think
Thats what i think too. MC Outside relationship it's toxic. Story is only going on for how long now 1-2months ? And they almost broke up so many times and without Sage's intervention maybe it would've been even worse.

I think there'll be solo paths for Josy and Maya even with friends route. I wouldn't make a flag for feelings otherwise and AFAIK that flag almost changed nothing ? With throuple path what you said would be the case after EP9(if there'll be solo paths) you will choose who you're going to spend your time with and end up in the solo path.

Three way relationships doesn't work when i think about it(that's why i don't like harem too) when 2 people in this relationships gets more attached other would feel left alone and like a third wheel in this case if MC and Josy gets more attached Maya would be left alone or vice versa. I don't think DPC will keep up the throuple but he might surprise us.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Darkwen

Darkwen

Devoted Member
Nov 10, 2020
8,293
14,501
814
Thats what i think too. MC Outside relationship it's toxic. Story is only going on for how long now 1-2months ? And they almost broke up so many times and without Sage's intervention maybe it would've been even worse.

Three way relationships doesn't work when i think about it(that's why i don't like harem too) when 2 people in this relationships gets more attached other would feel left alone and like a third wheel in this case if MC and Josy gets more attached Maya would be left alone or vice versa. I don't think DPC will keep up the throuple but he might surprise us.
I agree with that, even if MC stay's balance with Josy and Maya I feel like DPC is going to make you pick one of them by the end
 

daxil94

Member
Aug 27, 2019
105
164
134
I agree with that, even if MC stay's balance with Josy and Maya I feel like DPC is going to make you pick one of them by the end
I updated my post about this.
I think there'll be solo paths for Josy and Maya even with friends route. I wouldn't make a flag for feelings otherwise and AFAIK that flag almost changed nothing ? With throuple path what you said would be the case after EP9(if there'll be solo paths) you will choose who you're going to spend your time with and end up in the solo path.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Darkwen

Kpyna

Active Member
Dec 16, 2022
710
2,463
379
I know what you mean. But I don't need to play the other branches, because I can read more than enough information about the other branches here in the forum. If there is something interesting, I look at the scripts and pictures in the game folder.
Ok then...

I wrote this theory before we knew so Chad and Troy were gay. That was 2 years ago.
(y)

The only problem is Chad. I think to myself so he is bisexual. Josy mentions in EP8 so she hopes for Sage that Chad is bisexual. It's written. A girl like Sage is not going to go years without having sex with her boyfriend. Besides, Sage didn't believe her mother. If Chad never fucked Sage, then Sage would have believed Jade right away. No, no, Chad is at least bisexual.

End of EP3 learned from Maya so she doesn't trust her father's lies anymore. What lies? It will probably be about the college money. I figure so Maya and Josy tried to frame Patrick and the whole thing was Derek's idea. How? With a beard. But Patrick was suspicious and didn't pay the college money. A ladylike guy? Who? Troy. Patrick saw him walking. This already looks gay. Troy was the beard of Maya.
View attachment 2778172

I can well imagine so that the MC in the Gym of EP8 was tricked by Josy, Maya, Chad and Troy. He was supposed to catch Chad and Troy.

Many always forget so Maya attended college more often during her high school years. That's what Josy thinks in EP5. In EP3 we learn so Maya dated several guys but didn't have sex with guy. So Maya has been dating college guys and found the right one with Troy to start a Bart relationship. After, Josy and Maya hid things and lied to the MC, the MC would lose trust in Maya uand Josy. So the MC has to be prepared. The bad thing will be so that the blackmail photo what Chad got will show Maya together with Chad and Troy. I am looking forward to seeing how Sage and the MC will react to this photo. I only know one thing so a lot of people are scared of it.
Amazing ability to combine white and black in one post o_O

Josy said she hopes that he is bi- because otherwise she feels bad for Sage.

She probably cheated on him (it's still unclear moment) or used toys (she have a great collection). But Jade words have to rely on some reason and points. Probably she knew the truth (it's still unclear how much hidden CCTV here and there in campus and who stay besides it) and tried to warn Sage, but she didn't trust her. Sage started to suspect Chad because she thought that he is cheating on her and use the steroids and dick problems as an excuse.
How about Sage words that guys usually don't reject her? (Preps party, conversation in Tybalt's room, MC must not be on her path). What's this if not a signs that she probably cheated on Chad with guys, which "usually don't reject her".

I will not comment a lot the last and most fantastic part about J&M and Chad & Troy :alien: :HideThePain:

You clearly know Maya's reasons not being with guys. She explained that and we even saw a short but bright flashback from the school. Patrick revealed their relationship in the last months before the college. There was a couple of months gap from their early summer road trip and actual game events. Josy past and expirience with guys are still foggy, but probably we will not learn a lot because of 18 years border and regulations. But she studied in one school with Maya and Derek for years.
 

Jumbi

With my good eye closed
Donor
Feb 17, 2020
1,756
5,213
739
It is clear that from Maya these feelings are not mutual, at this moment for sure.
If everything is obvious with Josy, then Maya seems to have cooled off towards MC and perceives him as a friend. I don't even know how DPC intends to build Maya's solo outside of the group.
I wouldn't rule out so hastily Maya's feelings for the MC. Kpyna made a good point on his reply, which I quote below, especially the part in bold is of significance. No two people express themselves exactly the same. Maya's and Josy's personalities are quite different after all. And as more than one member here has stated it before, Maya is so sadly accustomed to feel disappointed or even directly rejected by the people who supposedly should care the most for her (hello cunt Patrick!), that being overcatious and reseved is the most natural path for her. But that does not mean she doesn't care or feel anything.

And on top of all that, having feelings for a boy was alien ground for her until very recently. But Derek sees it clear as day in his sister's eyes, when he surprises her and the MC kissing in that scene from season 1 (can't remember the exact episode now), that she's getting feelings for Fuckface.


The only thing I would like to say, that you link and refer to Josy feelings expressions as to the standard or kind of. While my point is that it depends on people personality and character. Why that introvert thing is even bringed up? Because such type of people hide their emotions and express them more strictly and modest. I think it's the reason which makes you think so that Maya doesn't have solid feelings for MC or they are weaker than Josys.
 
Last edited:

dalli_x

Engaged Member
Jul 7, 2017
3,746
8,067
769
Ok then...


(y)


Amazing ability to combine white and black in one post o_O

Josy said she hopes that he is bi- because otherwise she feels bad for Sage.

She probably cheated on him (it's still unclear moment) or used toys (she have a great collection). But Jade words have to rely on some reason and points. Probably she knew the truth (it's still unclear how much hidden CCTV here and there in campus and who stay besides it) and tried to warn Sage, but she didn't trust her. Sage started to suspect Chad because she thought that he is cheating on her and use the steroids and dick problems as an excuse.
How about Sage words that guys usually don't reject her? (Preps party, conversation in Tybalt's room, MC must not be on her path). What's this if not a signs that she probably cheated on Chad with guys, which "usually don't reject her".

I will not comment a lot the last and most fantastic part about J&M and Chad & Troy :alien: :HideThePain:

You clearly know Maya's reasons not being with guys. She explained that and we even saw a short but bright flashback from the school. Patrick revealed their relationship in the last months before the college. There was a couple of months gap from their early summer road trip and actual game events. Josy past and expirience with guys are still foggy, but probably we will not learn a lot because of 18 years border and regulations. But she studied in one school with Maya and Derek for years.
Maya said in EP6 so that not everything is black and white. The result would be gray.:ROFLMAO:
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Kpyna

Chutoro

Member
Jun 22, 2020
110
228
53
Speaking of toxic relationships, which relationship of the MC do you guys think is the most toxic? (It does not have to be one of the LIs, more in general). One that comes to my mind is the relationship with Tommy...
 

KАRАMBA

Engaged Member
Jan 6, 2021
3,716
11,125
688
But Jade words have to rely on some reason and points. Probably she knew the truth (it's still unclear how much hidden CCTV here and there in campus and who stay besides it) and tried to warn Sage, but she didn't trust her.
Jade didn't know anything about Chad for sure. She just assumed. Seriously, do you think if she had proof that Chad was gay, she wouldn't have shown it to Sage? She would have shown right away. Parents are very restless people, especially when it comes to the health of children. It's no secret that among gays, the incidence of AIDS is higher. And at least for this reason, if Jade knew for sure that Chad was gay, she would do anything to stop Chad and Sage communicating. I am 100% sure of this.
 

iggy.

Member
Mar 24, 2022
229
629
268
That's interesting.
Stephen Burke apparently didn't want to attend the preps party in the first place. That also puts the Mona thing in a different light. But why did he show up anyway?

Stephen thought that Jade had something else in mind and probably wanted to meet another woman who had a Rooster shock just before. Cathy. She canceled because she didn't need a fuck, she needed good friends. So Stephen reorganized that and went to the preps party.
View attachment 2778253

The guy is a pimp, he was testing out and fucking Camilla and Mona. That's why Mona left college, she couldnt do it.
 

I'm Canadian bub

Active Member
Mar 9, 2019
646
2,237
437
It is clear that from Maya these feelings are not mutual, at this moment for sure.
If everything is obvious with Josy, then Maya seems to have cooled off towards MC and perceives him as a friend. I don't even know how DPC intends to build Maya's solo outside of the group.
You know I've seen this sentiment being announced by several different members. At first, I thought it was just a joke, but seeing the discourse happening now I think y'all are serious. I realize I'm replying to you Geralt but my reply is more to everyone having this conversation.

Maya's feelings haven't grown shallower for the MC so much as her feelings towards her own uncertain future are simply overshadowing them. Many have already pointed out her character traits and how they define her behaviour. Knowing this it only makes sense that her, frankly, hatchling relationship with Fuckface is not taking precedence over trying to identify a path she can walk on steady ground.

If she can have that and have the MC and/or Josy with her; great! If she can have those things and a great college experience; splendid. If she can have all that and still have a relationship with her family; fucking miraculous! But at this point in the narrative, that all seems like a fantasy, and she's not like Josy who likes to live in dreams and imagine that everything will just work out if she just has her loved ones around her. Maya is more focused on finding real solutions and having grown up with negativity from most of her loved ones her view of the world has developed to show her she can't have those things until she has security.

Maya rarely got security and support from her loved ones whereas Josy more commonly did so she does what many introverted neglected young adults learn to do: compartmentalize and grow a tunnel vision. Focus on one thing at a time and keep emotions to a minimum until you've achieved your goal. It's harder for those individuals to embrace their emotions, especially the strongest emotions like love and fear.

Maya's love of horror movies portrays her disconnection from her fears; it's not that she doesn't feel fear but she disassociates from them regularly to avoid feeling overwhelmed by them, and watching horror movies is great practice to do so. That's just one example I could give many more but I grow tired and today is my day off. There is a great deal extra explanation I wished to provide but meh I'll just let it rot in my brain.

Hopefully, my brain allows me to sleep but if not I'll just keep watching movies on Netflix until I do. Let me post this before I completely lose the plot though.

Cheers bub.
 

KАRАMBA

Engaged Member
Jan 6, 2021
3,716
11,125
688
Great game. But I just don't like the situation where the MC gets mad at Josy and Maya. I feel like he is so childish.
Yes, you're right, he's acting stupid in that situation. But, thanks to this stupid reaction, Fuckface gets on the true and wonderful path - the Quinn path. Therefore, in this case, stupidity has benefited.
 

Joshy92

Message Maven
Mar 25, 2021
14,469
37,598
1,018
I have to strongly disagree with those that say Maya doesn't have strong feelings for the mc.
Before she met him, she thought she was a lesbian but her feelings for him are so strong
She doesn't even know if she is a lesbian or bisexual.
Plus, you know she has some pretty big problems to deal with
Before she can focus on love.

Also, I can just tell she love me.... Oops I meant loves the mc
So come on guys don't lose hope
Maya & I will prove love can defeat anything!!!
 

felicemastronzo

Message Maven
May 17, 2020
12,254
23,213
1,029
maybe my opinion is also related to an anagraphic aspect, indeed it surely will be, but I appreciate much more a balanced character like Maya (and Bella is very similar) than overly emotional characters like Josy (and Jill for example)

to think that Maya does not reciprocate MC's feelings is rather naïve, especially in the context of an AVN :ROFLMAO: :ROFLMAO: , only that REALISTICALLY these feelings are not Maya's only priority in life as she is called upon to deal with another emergency that takes priority. even with respect to Josy the issue of the loan takes priority, in the aftermath of Patrick's unexpected visit, Maya begins to reason about whether she should devote herself to her studies and put the affair with Josy on hold, with all the risk of losing her permanently.

now the whole loan storyline is rather stretched and not very believable, but since this is being proposed to us by DPC we have to believe it. Faced with the possibility of no longer being able to attend college and having to pay off a lifetime of debt that she can never repay, it is believable that Maya cannot let go of dreams of love and still have to maintain some lucidity (and in this it is ironic enough that the reason for friction with Josy is that for once Maya wants to have fun and forget, at least for the Halloween party, about her financial problems, by the way to think that saving money for the party costume might make a difference is very.... Jillish)

Maya, like Bella, is the only one who remains believable even in the role of MC's friend; MC doesn't love her back? she gets over it, doesn't show him a grudge, and gets on with her life. I prefer this to Josy who every first chapter of the season goes to MC to make sure he has not forgotten her and if anything instill some doubts in him about his current relationship (not coming forward, but hoping he will), or Jill who after deciding that anyway MC is not the man for her still has a beef with the fact that he is dating Bella or otherwise decides to show up at the Halloween party to make him regret what he missed...this subordinate role, which in an AVN is also fine, is still sad and pathetic...

even Zoey, forgetting the interlude steeped in failure, has this ability to be believable as both friend and lover, seems to me a great merit in DPC's construction of the character
 
Last edited:

KАRАMBA

Engaged Member
Jan 6, 2021
3,716
11,125
688
I have to strongly disagree with those that say Maya doesn't have strong feelings for the mc.
Before she met him, she thought she was a lesbian but her feelings for him are so strong
She doesn't even know if she is a lesbian or bisexual.
Plus, you know she has some pretty big problems to deal with
Before she can focus on love.

Also, I can just tell she love me.... Oops I meant loves the mc
So come on guys don't lose hope
Maya & I will prove love can defeat anything!!!
You're selfish.:cautious: You disappear yourself, and you drag a naive Fuckface into the same swamp. Leave him. He'll be much better with Quinn. They are made for each other. Or Fuckface was made for Quinn, no matter.
 
4.70 star(s) 1,741 Votes