Yeah you don't seem to know what a logical fallacy is because it is absolutely not a logical fallacy. It is very clearly emotional which has little to do with logic. Once again, it doesn't matter if he screwed someone else when they were not together. They were not together(and still aren't) so acting like he betrayed her in some way is bullshit. To be perfectly honest, the whole scene s stupid. The scene that happens with Cathy is nothing more than a blowjob, she had no reason to even take her panties off, much less leave them in the car. And, once again, this isn't real life, this is a VN. In the world of VN's it's pretty rare to have consequences to actions of that nature, especially when you were not with the person when you did it. Again, the ONLY thing she should be upset about is that he chose to do it in her car.I don't agree with how yossa999 put it and no, we are not responsible for another person's feelings, but acting as if Bella's decision to reject a Fuckface who gets involved with her co-worker in her car is illogical, is itself a logical fallacy. Her feelings may be the reason she rejects him but her decision is entirely logical because she doesn't wish to be involved with a young adult who evidently can't keep his dick in his pants. It is defined repetitively in the narrative that it just isn't in her character to get involved with an obvious womanizer. I imagine all the MC's dalliances will be scrutinized by her once she learns of them.