Gamb24

New Member
Mar 13, 2024
10
7
Coincedentally the Tybalt issue came up a couple of days ago as well, and many ideas were said, but nothing is known yet. It could be something like the moosehead being stolen (although Derek and the DIKs have shown it in clucks many time already), photographic proof that Derek turned on the sprinkler, proof of the preps visiting the DIK Halloween party (to create an internal conflict) to about anything else.

About Mel's and Sarah's secret: We do know that they knew about Chad being gay and maybe even about his relationship with Troy. I don't think however that this is the only secret they were talking about, but it very well could be.
When did we find out that Mel and Sarah know about Chad being gay? I must have missed that.
 

Gamb24

New Member
Mar 13, 2024
10
7
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

My guess is that the letter isn't about him, it's about something that he could use or gives him power. Maybe even to a degree where MC will have to talk to him and try to keep his knowledge to himself. That way every time that MC provoked him or angered him would backfire.

So far Tybalt has been nothing else but a victim and idiot, it was way too easy to make fun of him. Maybe it's time for him to dish out some revenge.
Except for the pic of Chad and Troy, all other letters were about stuff on the DIK's laptop, which probably got hacked by Magnar. My assumption is that the content of the letter depends on MC choices so far. F.e. if MC had sex with Jade and showed that at the Hell Week celebration, then it's a pic of that. If MC didn't had sex with Jade, then DPC will just create something from the DIK's past that was in the folders that MC had no access to.
 

MiltonPowers

Twins Basil! Twins!
Donor
Jul 26, 2023
11,840
25,590
The second thing that stood out for me during my second playthrough of the whole game was that it either never got revealed or that I missed it what Mel's and Sarah's secret is when it comes to Chad. It's obviously not an affair. Did I miss it when that got revealed or do we have no clue so far?
It hasn't been revealed, but the prevailing theory is that Mel & Troy are brother/sister (and that Sarah and Melanie know all about Chad/Troy). This is a pivot from the original widespread theory that Chad was cheating with Mel. When that was proved false, people switched to the sibling theory.

But, what if, Melanie's throuple relationship was her, Chad & Troy, and the boys fell in love and left her behind. :unsure: :ROFLMAO:
 
  • Haha
Reactions: CoalaMoan

Chillout1984

Engaged Member
Nov 15, 2020
2,815
1,698
It hasn't been revealed, but the prevailing theory is that Mel & Troy are brother/sister (and that Sarah and Melanie know all about Chad/Troy). This is a pivot from the original widespread theory that Chad was cheating with Mel. When that was proved false, people switched to the sibling theory.

But, what if, Melanie's throuple relationship was her, Chad & Troy, and the boys fell in love and left her behind. :unsure: :ROFLMAO:
If what Mel say is true (which I'm pretty sure of), that isn't the case :p

ml "I ended up leaving them. Michelle - my friend - is still with the guy, I think. We don't talk that much today."
 

felicemastronzo

Devoted Member
May 17, 2020
11,961
22,942
It hasn't been revealed, but the prevailing theory is that Mel & Troy are brother/sister (and that Sarah and Melanie know all about Chad/Troy). This is a pivot from the original widespread theory that Chad was cheating with Mel. When that was proved false, people switched to the sibling theory.

But, what if, Melanie's throuple relationship was her, Chad & Troy, and the boys fell in love and left her behind. :unsure: :ROFLMAO:
A theory based solely on the fact that for dpc, surnames are shrouded in absolute secrecy :ROFLMAO: :ROFLMAO:
 

MilesEdgeworth

Engaged Member
Nov 8, 2021
2,623
3,287
True, but we all know how extremely emotional he is when it comes to when his pride is hurt ;) That's why I doubt this would be his face if it really was something bad about him.
He would probably be celebrating if it was something about his enemies. Whatever it was, it left him emotionless and shocked. Perhaps it was something about either his mom or dad.
My guess is that the letter isn't about him, it's about something that he could use or gives him power. Maybe even to a degree where MC will have to talk to him and try to keep his knowledge to himself. That way every time that MC provoked him or angered him would backfire.

So far Tybalt has been nothing else but a victim and idiot, it was way too easy to make fun of him. Maybe it's time for him to dish out some revenge.
Except for the pic of Chad and Troy, all other letters were about stuff on the DIK's laptop, which probably got hacked by Magnar. My assumption is that the content of the letter depends on MC choices so far. F.e. if MC had sex with Jade and showed that at the Hell Week celebration, then it's a pic of that. If MC didn't had sex with Jade, then DPC will just create something from the DIK's past that was in the folders that MC had no access to.
The more I think about it, the more I think there was something in that letter that could either fuck over tybalt or the preps in general. Knowing that the nerds are hoping to destroy all other frats, that makes the most sense.
 
  • Like
Reactions: felicemastronzo

Gamb24

New Member
Mar 13, 2024
10
7
He would probably be celebrating if it was something about his enemies. Whatever it was, it left him emotionless and shocked. Perhaps it was something about either his mom or dad.

The more I think about it, the more I think there was something in that letter that could either fuck over tybalt or the preps in general. Knowing that the nerds are hoping to destroy all other frats, that makes the most sense.
Good point about wanting to hurt/destroy the preps. If that's the case, then I bet that it's a pic of the one prep buying drugs from Quinn.

But I don't think that it's about the preps. My guess is that it's a pic of his father, Stephen Burke getting a service from one of Quinn's girls. The whole topic of Mona refusing to have sex with Stephen Burke and then disappearing got somewhat lost since Mona left. Mona surely wasn't the first that Stephen Burke wanted to meet with, she was only the first who refused him.
 

TomUK

Engaged Member
Sep 28, 2021
3,182
2,329
Coincedentally the Tybalt issue came up a couple of days ago as well, and many ideas were said, but nothing is known yet. It could be something like the moosehead being stolen (although Derek and the DIKs have shown it in clucks many time already), photographic proof that Derek turned on the sprinkler, proof of the preps visiting the DIK Halloween party (to create an internal conflict) to about anything else.

About Mel's and Sarah's secret: We do know that they knew about Chad being gay and maybe even about his relationship with Troy. I don't think however that this is the only secret they were talking about, but it very well could be.
I think Tybolt's letter has to do with the HOTs, Magnar wants to get rid of all the frats and sororities, his only chance to get rid of the HOTs is probably through Tybolt and Tybolt isn't worried it might close the Preps down as well, cause he's an idiot and he'll see it as getting back at the people who have humiliated him, like his sister, Jill and the other Preps always snickering behind his back.

Ant's letter was about Ashley being with Derek. Chad's letter was most likely about his secret with Troy. Dawe's letter ... who cares? But what is Tybalt's letter about?

Any ideas?
Ant's was probably about Derek fucking Ashley, probably in Derek's room when it was just a storeroom, Dawe's was a pic confirming Derek or mc put the condom in his shaker, and Chad's was probably his gay liaison with Troy.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bonerland

Vill3m

Newbie
Jul 25, 2022
87
343
Yes, it doesn't like mentioning famous studios, works, or people and considers such requests a copyright violation.
:ROFLMAO:
Yeah, ChatGPT couldn't quite figure out what was triggering the restrictions, but from what I was able to find online it seems OpenAI has cracked down on that feature once it got popular. Luckily Grok is less restricted, although it likes to take more "artistic" liberties.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
 
Last edited:

TomUK

Engaged Member
Sep 28, 2021
3,182
2,329
When did we find out that Mel and Sarah know about Chad being gay? I must have missed that.
I think like others have said, that Mel might be Troy's sister, so she would know about it and she wouldn't keep it secret from Sarah, but John must be close to Chad if he is allowed in to their little get together at the HOTs party, so he probably knows about it as well.
 

Chillout1984

Engaged Member
Nov 15, 2020
2,815
1,698
I think Tybolt's letter has to do with the HOTs, Magnar wants to get rid of all the frats and sororities, his only chance to get rid of the HOTs is probably through Tybolt and Tybolt isn't worried it might close the Preps down as well, cause he's an idiot and he'll see it as getting back at the people who have humiliated him, like his sister, Jill and the other Preps always snickering behind his back.
Magnar doesn't seem to want to bring the HOTs down though, only the frats:

mg "The tri-alphas, the alpha nu omegas, the delta iota kappas... Finally, they will all get what's coming to them."
mg "And before they realized what happened, they would have punched each other out."
mg "When we're done, the only frat worth its salt on campus is ours."
 

Hahn1900

Well-Known Member
Jan 3, 2021
1,604
3,495
I think like others have said, that Mel might be Troy's sister, so she would know about it and she wouldn't keep it secret from Sarah, but John must be close to Chad if he is allowed in to their little get together at the HOTs party, so he probably knows about it as well.
Besides... the signs are clear about it... Sarah and Mel act suspisous all the time. Hiding something from Sage, act weird around the whole deal and so on... They are close with Chad, which is shown too...

Sage thaught initially that Mel or Sarah cheats with Chad, but she saw that she was wrong about that, even if you dont tell her that Chad is gay.

There is simply no reason for Mel and Sarah to act like they do around Chad if they dont know whats up.

So we can say... its NOT a "known fact" that mel or Sarah know about Chad being Gay... but its a very fair assumption.

Besides... at this point it doesnt really matter anymore i guess. The only thing left in that storyplot is that Chad has to become clean about it, which he will be after everythign with Magnar is solved i guess. And after that Mel and Sarah will propably tell Sage "sorry, we knew but couldnt tell you" or so.
 
  • Like
Reactions: John Ness
4.70 star(s) 1,634 Votes