NewTricks

Forum Fanatic
Nov 1, 2017
5,408
11,834
823
I've held to the theory that James was dead for a long time. Pretty much since we got our first look at him in Bella's flashback and he was acting like Drop Dead Fred while people were looking at Bella like you would look at a person who was talking to themselves. However, it wouldn't surprise me if he was the mysterious porch visitor. Of course, it wouldn't surprise me if it was indeed Lynette visiting, who never really died either and has been spending two decades in a hospital in Boca Raton. This VN is a ridiculous soap opera and you pretty much need to embrace the madness.
 
  • Like
Reactions: somefancy

Better Cock Spock

Half Vulcan, Half Simp
Donor
Jul 29, 2017
13,178
35,877
1,054
I've held to the theory that James was dead for a long time. Pretty much since we got our first look at him in Bella's flashback and he was acting like Drop Dead Fred while people were looking at Bella like you would look at a person who was talking to themselves. However, it wouldn't surprise me if he was the mysterious porch visitor. Of course, it wouldn't surprise me if it was indeed Lynette visiting, who never really died either and has been spending two decades in a hospital in Boca Raton. This VN is a ridiculous soap opera and you pretty much need to embrace the madness.
When you say "mysterious porch visitor", you're not talking about the end of Episode 11 are you? Because Maya opened the locked room, not the front door/door leading to front door.
 

somefancy

Newbie
Jul 25, 2020
31
38
48
I don't have any kids yet, so I'm wondering would it make sense to set up a baby's room on a different floor then the one you sleep on? I would think you'd want it to be closer to your bedroom in case of any emergencies.
It doesn't. Parents typically have their child in the same room as them for the first couple of years.
I was thinking it might be child related but it doesn't make sense because Bella never mentioned this kind of stuff before. Maybe it is some sort of "worshiping" room for James.
 

FalconLover420

Engaged Member
Nov 23, 2020
2,777
3,217
419
I've held to the theory that James was dead for a long time. Pretty much since we got our first look at him in Bella's flashback and he was acting like Drop Dead Fred while people were looking at Bella like you would look at a person who was talking to themselves. However, it wouldn't surprise me if he was the mysterious porch visitor. Of course, it wouldn't surprise me if it was indeed Lynette visiting, who never really died either and has been spending two decades in a hospital in Boca Raton. This VN is a ridiculous soap opera and you pretty much need to embrace the madness.
The thing about the mysterious porch visitor, could be the MC as they share the same shirt outline coming back after taking Derek to the hospital to console Bella now that the contents/secrets have been exposed to the gang.

I personally believe its something very mild like the storage of her husband's belongings like his boots and all that. The reason I say this is due to the context of the story, her husband has been gone/missing/dead for 3 years and she still has the ring and trying to remain faithful to him (Unless you are on her route, then faithful be damned and she has guilt). We see this closet opened only once and that was when Bella went and got some clothes for the MC to wear for yoga.
 

Derek in a Bush

Well-Known Member
May 7, 2024
1,157
882
142
It doesn't. Parents typically have their child in the same room as them for the first couple of years.
I was thinking it might be child related but it doesn't make sense because Bella never mentioned this kind of stuff before. Maybe it is some sort of "worshiping" room for James.
Maybe Bella is prego
 

Better Cock Spock

Half Vulcan, Half Simp
Donor
Jul 29, 2017
13,178
35,877
1,054
The thing about the mysterious porch visitor, could be the MC as they share the same shirt outline coming back after taking Derek to the hospital to console Bella now that the contents/secrets have been exposed to the gang.

I personally believe its something very mild like the storage of her husband's belongings like his boots and all that. The reason I say this is due to the context of the story, her husband has been gone/missing/dead for 3 years and she still has the ring and trying to remain faithful to him (Unless you are on her route, then faithful be damned and she has guilt). We see this closet opened only once and that was when Bella went and got some clothes for the MC to wear for yoga.
We see it opened once before at the end of Episode 3, but Bella was all alone.
1744780951986.jpeg
The moment you're talking about in Episode 5, she doesn't go to the locked room, she goes to her bedroom.
1744781032664.jpeg 1744781041486.jpeg
 
  • Thinking Face
Reactions: FalconLover420

NotEthan;P

Newbie
Dec 27, 2017
36
68
225
Don't be an asshole Milton :cautious:
I know what's in there, check it out: a leaked preview of Episode 12's opening scene!
View attachment 4749260 View attachment 4749262 View attachment 4749264 View attachment 4749254
And of course, MC's reaction depends on if youre dating Bella or not.
Bella path: Oh hell yeah!
Different path: Fuck, I made the wrong choice!
Both MC and Maya's face are a mix between being puzzled and a bit of shock but not too much, with maybe a bit of sadness too, at least for the MC? Whatever it is, it's not something too crazy nor too bad.
 
  • Like
Reactions: somefancy

Better Cock Spock

Half Vulcan, Half Simp
Donor
Jul 29, 2017
13,178
35,877
1,054
Both MC and Maya's face are a mix between being puzzled and a bit of shock but not too much, with maybe a bit of sadness too, at least for the MC? Whatever it is, it's not something too crazy nor too bad.
I'm of the opinion that whatever is in there is merely surprising, not shocking, and will be a big nothing in the end. No crazy psycho shit, no Acting Lessons nonsense.
 

Better Cock Spock

Half Vulcan, Half Simp
Donor
Jul 29, 2017
13,178
35,877
1,054
But what does mc mean when he said” if I knew I would’ve called for help” or something like that ??
Still unknown, but it doesn't have to be something sinister.
Actually thinking about in relation to the library scene in Episode 3, I can see why the MC narration talks about calling for help.

Bella is completely heartbroken over losing her child—miscarriage, or SIDS, or even somehow indirectly being her fault, hence asking James for forgiveness. It's not just James she thinks she's betraying by hooking up with MC, but the kid too—and is holding onto the desperate idea that James is still alive somewhere. Because if he can return, then so can the kid (metaphorically, I just mean have another child). Broad strokes, I can see that something like this.
I actually had another idea that I didn't mention in my original comment, but you are hovering around it with the talk of double meanings and Bella being referred to as a mom, so here it is: her child was named James Roberts Jr.
All speculation of course.
 

Whitecat2

Newbie
Dec 6, 2024
18
14
71
People. Who noticed the new, as yet unnamed girl? The blonde, with a hairdo similar to Sally's? She first appears at yoga class, on the left in the front row. Then at Nora's class, she sits in front of MC. And finally at the Christmas party, she's in the 2nd floor living room talking to Chen and we're finally asked to get her a drink. I assume this is the ghoul from the Halloween party.
 

TonyMurray

Conversation Conqueror
Apr 8, 2024
6,588
12,531
774
People. Who noticed the new, as yet unnamed girl? The blonde, with a hairdo similar to Sally's? She first appears at yoga class, on the left in the front row. Then at Nora's class, she sits in front of MC. And finally at the Christmas party, she's in the 2nd floor living room talking to Chen and we're finally asked to get her a drink. I assume this is the ghoul from the Halloween party.
No idea who you're talking about. Are you sure she's from this game? :ROFLMAO:
 
  • Haha
Reactions: ffive and Vill3m

Better Cock Spock

Half Vulcan, Half Simp
Donor
Jul 29, 2017
13,178
35,877
1,054
No idea who you're talking about. Are you sure she's from this game? :ROFLMAO:
Damn it you stole my obvious joke :HideThePain:
People. Who noticed the new, as yet unnamed girl? The blonde, with a hairdo similar to Sally's? She first appears at yoga class, on the left in the front row. Then at Nora's class, she sits in front of MC. And finally at the Christmas party, she's in the 2nd floor living room talking to Chen and we're finally asked to get her a drink. I assume this is the ghoul from the Halloween party.
Yeah we've all noticed her, and she is indeed the Thristy Ghoul from Halloween. I'm guessing you didn't get her second interaction after getting her the drink?
 
4.70 star(s) 1,727 Votes