Darkwen

Devoted Member
Nov 10, 2020
8,119
14,244
763
So since the rest are doing it why not

Looks:
Josy =Josy =Josy=Josy> Bella > Sage

Personality:
Josy> Bella > Sage> Jill > should go to walmart

Sexuality & Confidence:
Josy Alady = Josy Alady Alady Alady> Bella> Sage > Maya dorm party

Baggage (easy to heavy):
What Baggage Josy perfect > Jill > Sage = Bella > as I said more baggage then a Italian family on vaction Maya

Future (Best to worst):
Josy > >>>>>you kidding there only one girl I have a future with
 

treechild1

Engaged Member
Nov 16, 2024
2,020
3,267
341
So since the rest are doing it why not

Looks:
Josy =Josy =Josy=Josy> Bella > Sage

Personality:
Josy> Bella > Sage> Jill > should go to walmart

Sexuality & Confidence:
Josy Alady = Josy Alady Alady Alady> Bella> Sage > Maya dorm party

Baggage (easy to heavy):
What Baggage Josy perfect > Jill > Sage = Bella > as I said more baggage then a Italian family on vaction Maya

Future (Best to worst):
Josy > >>>>>you kidding there only one girl I have a future with
You seem to be applying a very heavily weighted bell curve here. But, for you, this checks out. You pass. (y) Except that Walmart statement… and the Italian baggage crack. What is wrong with you?:HideThePain::Kappa:
 

-d2d-

Formerly 'd2dacameron'
Feb 26, 2020
2,061
2,746
410
With Jill for me I don't know if you'd call it baggage but I find her route a bit of a downer.

There's the Tybalt situation, sprinklers at preps, punching Tybalt, getting accused about taking things from her room etc etc.

Feels like unless you're purposefully playing safe, or even if you are in some cases, she's always got something to be unsure or mad about which makes her path a drag for me IMO.
 

Geralt From Rivia

Conversation Conqueror
Jun 15, 2022
7,855
50,681
812
I will expand on this further as I seem to have pissed off some people.

Looks are purely subjective so no point in explaining.


Personality:
1. Jill is the definition of innocence. She is always on her best behavior and is fiercely loyal. Never gets jealous, trusts you and forgives you completely after learning the truth about the Preps party. She is the dream girl personality-wise.
I'd like to make a correction here. Jill is jealous. We saw it when our idiot said he was going to meet Zoey. But Jill, being shy and having good manners, didn't want to start a fight, instead she poured out her heart to Sage. Jealousy is there, Jill just didn't show it so openly.
And her absolute trust is more a flaw. She should check our guy more, she should watch Bianca.
Besides, forgiving everything is also a flaw, people will use her for it. I would never forgive stolen money, MC should be in a blacklist for this forever.
 

Darkwen

Devoted Member
Nov 10, 2020
8,119
14,244
763
You seem to be applying a very heavily weighted bell curve here. But, for you, this checks out. You pass. (y) Except that Walmart statement… and the Italian baggage crack. What is wrong with you?:HideThePain::Kappa:
because it sounded funny :ROFLMAO: :ROFLMAO: :ROFLMAO: :ROFLMAO:, one day I'll be nice to Maya again :ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO:
I have very high standards :cool:
 
  • Thinking Face
Reactions: treechild1

NewTricks

Forum Fanatic
Nov 1, 2017
5,423
11,914
823
Do you even realize that you have all admitted liking Madame Rose ? :BootyTime:
Yes.

1745799682830.png
She has her good qualities. She always answers the phone on the first ring. Even though she has a similar build to Bella, I can look past it because she is kinder to strangers. Kindness counts. Oh, and she seems to be a fairly present wife and mother in that one scene during Sage's disasterous date. She just needs to lay off the essential oils. Just because she has problems saying no to people doesn't mean she has to buy everything that Jessica from high school sells on her Facebook page.
 

Better Cock Spock

Half Vulcan, Half Simp
Donor
Jul 29, 2017
13,393
36,712
1,054
That name smells vaguely familiar, why do you ask?
The real Madame Rose simp
So since the rest are doing it why not

Looks:
Josy =Josy =Josy=Josy> Bella > Sage

Personality:
Josy> Bella > Sage> Jill > should go to walmart

Sexuality & Confidence:
Josy Alady = Josy Alady Alady Alady> Bella> Sage > Maya dorm party

Baggage (easy to heavy):
What Baggage Josy perfect > Jill > Sage = Bella > as I said more baggage then a Italian family on vaction Maya

Future (Best to worst):
Josy > >>>>>you kidding there only one girl I have a future with
As long as Bella is your #1 when Josy is Number Alady, that's fine by me :giggle:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Darkwen

Maccabbee

Engaged Member
Mar 26, 2024
2,261
3,901
331
I'd like to make a correction here. Jill is jealous. We saw it when our idiot said he was going to meet Zoey. But Jill, being shy and having good manners, didn't want to start a fight, instead she poured out her heart to Sage. Jealousy is there, Jill just didn't show it so openly.
And her absolute trust is more a flaw. She should check our guy more, she should watch Bianca.
Besides, forgiving everything is also a flaw, people will use her for it. I would never forgive stolen money, MC should be in a blacklist for this forever.
Only if you were evil enough to steal money from Jill. I never did.
 
  • Like
Reactions: treechild1

Better Cock Spock

Half Vulcan, Half Simp
Donor
Jul 29, 2017
13,393
36,712
1,054
This was actually kinda hard when I got to Baggage and Future, since other than Jill, they all have different levels of problems at the moment (and some are choice dependent).
Looks.png Personality.png Sexuality.png Baggage.png Future.png
And it's all relative. Being last in something doesn’t mean zero, like not attractive at all or having no future.
 

JillybeanEnjoyer

Well-Known Member
Feb 19, 2021
1,416
3,579
349
Looks:
Sage > Jill > Josy > Bella > Maya

Personality:
Jill > Sage > Bella > Maya > Josy

Sexuality:
Sage > Bella > Josy > Maya >>> Jill

Baggage (most to least):
Bella >>> Maya >> Josy >> Sage > Jill

Future (best to worst):
Jill >>> Sage > Bella > Maya >>> Josy
 

treechild1

Engaged Member
Nov 16, 2024
2,020
3,267
341
Looks:
Sage > Jill > Josy > Bella > Maya

Personality:
Jill > Sage > Bella > Maya > Josy

Sexuality:
Sage > Bella > Josy > Maya >>> Jill

Baggage (most to least):
Bella >>> Maya >> Josy >> Sage > Jill

Future (best to worst):
Jill >>> Sage > Bella > Maya >>> Josy
Well… at least you mixed things up for each round. I can respect that.
on a side note: this format is starting to hurt my eyes. Is that just me?:confused:
 

shazba jnr

Active Member
Feb 3, 2024
556
4,756
329
Baggage (most to least):
Bella >>> Maya >> Josy >> Sage > Jill
How has Josy got more baggage than Sage or Jill?

Sage has the whole, "Can't express emotions, dysfunctional family, brother is Tybalt" sit going on.

And Jill has the "Poor little rich girl, dead sister, drunk father, distant mother and borderline retardedness" tropes on her shoulders.

What's Josy got? Maya? ... oh. :whistle:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lightaces
4.70 star(s) 1,734 Votes