Chillout1984

Forum Fanatic
Nov 15, 2020
5,168
3,286
No no, Maya might already know. If Maya didn't know, it does matter. And it still matters either way, it's not Josy's secret to share. And it's pretty obvious to anyone with a brain why it's a secret.
Again, then they should've been more careful. Everybody shares secrets with their besties if they overhear something "juicy". It's perfectly fine to do that here as well, especially she hasn't promised not to share the secret.
 
  • Disagree
Reactions: Sn1g

Macky009

Engaged Member
Oct 29, 2020
3,496
3,688
I disagree. Unless it's specifically told to her that it's a secret and that she shouldn't tell anyone, it's perfectly fine for her to tell it further. It's on the other party that they weren't careful enough while talking about it.
Again, then they should've been more careful. Everybody shares secrets with their besties if they overhear something "juicy". It's perfectly fine to do that here as well, especially she hasn't promised not to share the secret.
A teacher and a student are in relationship, that's so obvious that the relationship should not be publicize. I know they are all friends but MC should be the one to tell Sage not Josy. Unlike Maya who might know she did not spill the secret. Josy even spill the bean to Maya if you did not hangout with her in ep10
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sn1g

Better Cock Spock

Half Vulcan, Half Simp
Donor
Jul 29, 2017
11,916
32,354
A teacher and a student are in relationship, that's so obvious that the relationship should not be publicize. I know they are all friends but MC should be the one to tell Sage not Josy. Unlike Mays who might know she did not spill the secret.
Like I said, anyone with a brain would know why it's a secret.
ohh ok I still haven't done a bella path yet
Bro. What the fuck.
 

Chillout1984

Forum Fanatic
Nov 15, 2020
5,168
3,286
A teacher and a student are in relationship, that's so obvious that the relationship should not be publicize. I know they are all friends but MC should be the one to tell Sage not Josy. Unlike Mays who might know she did not spill the secret.
That's on Bella and Jill then. Also Josy has lots to gain by fucking them over.

Like I said, anyone with a brain would know why it's a secret.

Bro. What the fuck.
Yes, it's a secret, but everyone knows that the "rules" with secrets are that you only need to keep them if you promised it.
 

Better Cock Spock

Half Vulcan, Half Simp
Donor
Jul 29, 2017
11,916
32,354
Since we're on this topic, I wanted to bring up the scene where we tell Maya about Bella. I know I've mentioned this before, but it’s such a good moment between them, highlights how strong their friendship is. Maya is understandably surprised, but not only accepts it but even realizes that Maya herself and MC are now in the same boat, being forced to hide their love.

Now, if Josy didn't already spill the beans, I would have said Sage would be someone else that MC could trust with the secret. Sage is his best friend, and Maya his closest.
 

Macky009

Engaged Member
Oct 29, 2020
3,496
3,688
That's on Bella and Jill then. Also Josy has lots to gain by fucking them over.
Why would it be on Jill and Bella. Jill is talking privately with Bella and discuss the potential problem if Bella continue her relationship with mc. On the other hand Josy should just keep her mouth shut if she really is a friend. And it so obvious that is a secret because Bella and Jill went to kitchen to talk.

Yes, it's a secret, but everyone knows that the "rules" with secrets are that you only need to keep them if you promised it.
If you are a real friend even without telling it to you you should keep it a secret
 

Chillout1984

Forum Fanatic
Nov 15, 2020
5,168
3,286
Why would it be on Jill and Bella. Jill is talking privately with Bella and discuss the potential problem if Bella continue her relationship with mc. On the other hand Josy should just keep her mouth shut if she really is a friend. And it so obvious that is a secret because Bella and Jill went to kitchen to talk.


If you are a real friend even without telling it to you you should keep it a secret

1. They were talking in a room where it was easy to overhear them. It also seems they were talking at normal volume and not whispering. So yeah, that's on them.
2. Nah, you can always share secrets with friends. Maybe even they're the only exception to tell if you promised not to tell.
 

Macky009

Engaged Member
Oct 29, 2020
3,496
3,688
Since we're on this topic, I wanted to bring up the scene where we tell Maya about Bella. I know I've mentioned this before, but it’s such a good moment between them, highlights how strong their friendship is. Maya is understandably surprised, but not only accepts it but even realizes that Maya herself and MC are now in the same boat, being forced to hide their love.

Now, if Josy didn't already spill the beans, I would have said Sage would be someone else that MC could trust with the secret. Sage is his best friend, and Maya his closest.
One of the best part in that scene is when Maya admit to MC that she loved him. But instead of guilt tripping him, she just let him go and be good friends. Only available if mc is in a relationship with Josy and Maya
 

Darkwen

Conversation Conqueror
Nov 10, 2020
7,391
13,446
But you know Bella is best girl (and Josy is best-est girl for you). Your rankings even had her as the girl you would marry if Josy didn't exist. So what gives, you have all this time, use it :)
Which should tell you how much a like Josy that I can't play my second favorite girls path, when Im ready I'll do it
 
4.70 star(s) 1,714 Votes