felicemastronzo
Message Maven
- May 17, 2020
- 12,252
- 23,221
- 978
I don't think the value of this game will be measured by how happy Maya and Josy's ending will be, which is still basically a surprise in the game (personally quite unexpected).This is only his 2nd game and it's drastically different from their first, so who really knows what DPC will and won't do? Just because he had a psycho killer in the last game doesn't mean there will be one in this game, just because a LI died in the last game doesn't mean one will die here, and just because he made one game where a throuple didn't work out does not mean that will happen in this game.
If he wants to be labeled a one-trick pony, then by all means, go ahead and repeat all the same beats of the previous game, but the best writers/creators can turn their hand to different types of stories/genres, do different things, and not be repetitious. This game is just that, and the very nature of it does not make their relationship unlikely, unless DPC is a masochist who likes to play with his audience which I sincerely hope they're not. Not having a M&J ending is the same as not having a Sage ending, or a Jill ending, or a Bella ending, even when you do everything right because the dev has hard-coded a bad ending for them. Players wouldn't be happy about him doing this with any other LI, so M&J should be no exception.
if everything will happen with its own logic why should it be a problem? there is no need for a serial killer or a fire.
it does not even seem comparable to the situation of AL where one of the 4 LI was a scam, one was unreachable by itself, and in addition the happy ending to the triangle was denied.