I agree that she is one of the hottest and beautiful as well, to me the problem is not that she have a boyfriend, Sage has one too and Bella is married (Bella is my favorite) ,but you see the problem is her atittude she is more willing to cheat than to leave that relationship, the girl kiss you and them tell she has a BF, the girl says she feel bad about what she is doing and 5 min later is inviting you to stay and have sex, and she is pretty much ok with cheating as long she finds her other half in the process, Bella stoped herself and felled ashamed after, Sage was manipulating the MC to get what she wanted and later in the guitar lesson she thinks ( if its ok to chad do it so its for me ,not exactly her words but its something like that) so she is also at least having second thoughts, so the problem with Josy is her attitude, and that she seems to don't give a fuck about her BF and still refuse to leave him, she might do the same thing with the MC...