AchedCroissant
Conversation Conqueror
- May 29, 2020
- 6,175
- 28,636
- 934
Maya being Derek's sister made sense storywise, same thing with Burke as adoptive father to Sage.... Kids of MC mother's friends also make sense in the story... So it is safe to assume we need to have more then just some random similarities between 2 characters to even start assume there's family ties there.One thing I don't understand is why does everyone in B&R have to be related?
I'm tired of seeing literally the same theory on a weekly basis, that Josy and Jill are related, like there are no hints about it, it's not referenced or foreshadowed at all in the game. The whole damn thing starts on the basis of that they wear the same color of pants.Maya being Derek's sister made sense storywise, same thing with Burke as adoptive father to Sage.... Kids of MC mother's friends also make sense in the story... So it is safe to assume we need to have more then just some random similarities between 2 characters to even start assume there's family ties there.
so much so that now I am worried about why Maya wanted us to know her last name, it can not be a coincidenceOne thing I don't understand is why does everyone in B&R have to be related? It's something that hasn't been hinted or mentioned at all in the game, so chances are pretty low. Hell, I'd even put it in the Dalli territory of theories, where he just focuses on ONE, JUST ONE obscure detail and turns it into something that has like 0% chance of happening.
It won't be a big deal if it turns out to be true, but I seriously doubt it.
Melanie might be Troy's sister. They kinda look alike.so much so that now I am worried about why Maya wanted us to know her last name, it can not be a coincidence
the kinships serve to narratively create relationships that you don't have to explain, it's so because yes.
anyway now Melanie is in the picture to justify her meddling in the business between Sage and Chad, then the big mystery of Lynette and this one you made up I don't know why![]()
![]()
![]()
Dunno that, seems to me Melanie is the one struggling with how things went down in the Sage/Chad/Troy events while Sarah (or is that her name??) seems to be the one that rationalises their role without much trouble, something a sister would have aswell since there's no moral choice there, family first.... Not saying Sarah is Troy's sister just thinking Melanie is not.Melanie might be Troy's sister.
I stand up for my brothers, unlike you traitor.View attachment 1636229
How is your eyes? , have you clean it yet ? Properly, and not with Acid?! I guess not, because I wasn't talking to you![]()
Other option was that Melanie was Chad's sidechick, but last episode proved that theory wrong. So something weird is going on there, but I believe that she is Troy's sister and she's playing cover for them.Dunno that, seems to me Melanie is the one struggling with how things went down in the Sage/Chad/Troy events while Sarah (or is that her name??) seems to be the one that rationalises their role without much trouble, something a sister would have aswell since there's no moral choice there, family first.... Not saying Sarah is Troy's sister just thinking Melanie is not.
One of them is in your signature, so even though you are a little boy, I guess you can figure it out by yourself.What you talking about?I don't Support, Bella, neither Bianca, I just tolerate them. you should know this by now
![]()
![]()
Simp, this is your old avatar, it ain't even your sig. Take a hike, cause you lose like you always do.You really need to check your eyes. There is NO Bella in my signature.
. I guess, you are one of those who thought this was Bella ?! or you just wish it was
View attachment 1636250
Well, both Melanie and Sarah are in it together whatever it is, just seems to me Melanie is the one with a minor loyalty crisis, while Sarah seems more likely a character to be the one responsible for their part in the whole situation. Melanie is more go with the flow, while Sarah is more of a go-getter. And we all seen how DPC handled the "Sage father at the party" buildup, we get a revelation she's adopted in ep 8 for it all to make sense.... There's some link to Troy but there's been some party where Sage wasn't attending and things happened there... so maybe we get to see that in a flashback in ep.9Other option was that Melanie was Chad's sidechick, but last episode proved that theory wrong. So something weird is going on there, but I believe that she is Troy's sister and she's playing cover for them.
So you're telling me that we are getting a Troy, Chad and Stephen threesome flashback?Well, both Melanie and Sarah are in it together whatever it is, just seems to me Melanie is the one with a minor loyalty crisis, while Sarah seems more likely a character to be the one responsible for their part in the whole situation. Melanie is more go with the flow, while Sarah is more of a go-getter. And we all seen how DPC handled the "Sage father at the party" buildup, we get a revelation she's adopted in ep 8 for it all to make sense.... There's some link to Troy but there's been some party where Sage wasn't attending and things happened there... so maybe we get to see that in a flashback in ep.9![]()
it seems to me the oppositeWell, both Melanie and Sarah are in it together whatever it is, just seems to me Melanie is the one with a minor loyalty crisis, while Sarah seems more likely a character to be the one responsible for their part in the whole situation. Melanie is more go with the flow, while Sarah is more of a go-getter. And we all seen how DPC handled the "Sage father at the party" buildup, we get a revelation she's adopted in ep 8 for it all to make sense.... There's some link to Troy but there's been some party where Sage wasn't attending and things happened there... so maybe we get to see that in a flashback in ep.9![]()
If Josy and Jill are related based on the color of their pants what about Josy and Bella their hair style is kinda of close so they must be family rightI'm tired of seeing literally the same theory on a weekly basis, that Josy and Jill are related, like there are no hints about it, it's not referenced or foreshadowed at all in the game. The whole damn thing starts on the basis of that they wear the same color of pants.![]()
Yeah, that's going to be a problem for me and Chip during family gatherings. Because I'll end up beating the fuck out of that little bitch.If Josy and Jill are related based on the color of their pants what about Josy and Bella their hair style is kinda of close so they must be family right
View attachment 1636288
View attachment 1636289
Well saying kinda close might pushing it a bit but I can still see it or I just looking at Josy and Bella![]()
Doesn’t sage herself explain it? She’s avoiding him because he’s a kiss ass. At these parties he spends his time sucking up to people and it’s embarrassing.how does the fact that Sage's stepfather is Burke justify her wanting to avoid him (though so and so grateful to him) at the very Preps party, when Burke is present at BR all the time every day? even in Bella's library where Sage goes to study...
well at least it in the familyYeah, that's going to be a problem for me and Chip during family gatherings. Because I'll end up beating the fuck out of that little bitch.![]()
![]()
![]()
That's the weird part though - we've never seen Burke acting in the way she described him. He's never been anything but friendly, mild-mannered and diplomatic with other characters, but these descriptions vary so much that it's weird seeing it like that.Doesn’t sage herself explain it? She’s avoiding him because he’s a kiss ass. At these parties he spends his time sucking up to people and it’s embarrassing.
Day to day he isn’t around donors and alumni. At prep parties he’s acting differently and she doesn’t like that.
id have to replay to get direct quotes but my recollection was she didn’t like how he behaved at these parties so avoided him. Irony being she was there to raise money too.
If Josy and Jill are related based on the color of their pants what about Josy and Bella their hair style is kinda of close so they must be family right
View attachment 1636288
View attachment 1636289
Well saying kinda close might pushing it a bit but I can still see it or I just like looking at Josy and Bella![]()