Honestly I feel the same way about Josy. IMO Josy is super emotionally needy, she's very frightened of talking about anything serious, the fact that she resorts to lies when people ask her about the throuple after the halloween party is a huge turn off. I really don't like her declaration that she'd never introduce MC to her parents was another red flag. It's being addressed as a plotline now but her lack of character development has made her very boring to me.
Maya on the other hand is a lot more comfortable talking about things, she shows a sense of humor more often, she's even been a lot more adventurous, like at the dorm party, or at the halloween party behind the green screen, even the
scene in ep 11 she seems way more willing to push things than Josy. She's just more openly expressive of her feelings for MC and isn't scared to show it. Granted she has a pessimistic view of things, which isn't surprising considering her plot line. I've seen complaints that she's just too much of a downer, but to me that's a weird reason to dislike someone, everyone needs help sometimes.
Even if you put all that aside, I just find Maya more physically attractive than Josy.
Josy is still my favorite girl, but i agree to many things here.
But things changed. At first Maya was lying and a really closed book. Demand 100% honesty of MC, without even getting close to said 100% herself. The lack of honesty was something that bothered me a lot, not as much that she wasnt open about everything, no... its just the fact that she demanded 100% honesty of the MC without being that herself that bothered me a lot. If you demand something from others, you should give it yourself too. If you cant do that, dont demand it from others.
Josy never demanded such things, and was a little more open to the MC at the start.
But those things shifted a lot. With each episode Maya opened up more, and after episode 9 Josy began to seclude herself more and more.
That Maya opened up more in every regard was reasonable because of her character development. First telling MC about the family issues, than about the relationship issues with Josy, her concern about lacking experience with boys, until the point everything was out in the open after episode 10 with her family and whatnot.
Josys development goes in the opposite direction. But in my opionion DPC did a really bad job in that regard. Until episode 9 she was all peachy, fun, nice, overly friendly. And only here and there she said that she is a little self-concious about her hight. Wich is ok, she is a petite person. But thats something that makes her even more adorable (and yes, petite ladys are a huge turn on in real life for me too, and to be clear, petite doesnt mean "loli")... so, besides her small figure, nothing pointed in the direction that she basically questions her whole existence.
But out of the blue, everything is basic about her, and she is all depressed about that, is using social media to get popular and so on, thats so out of the blue and not reasonable at all. Its just... DPC thinking "ok, Mayas drama is done for, now i need to add drama to Josy... what can i do, what can i do... oh yes, she thinks she is only a basic girl and needs to change that making a social media presence" Thats just so bad and doesnt fit her character at all. If you force drama on a character like that, it should have been "hinted" beforehand that she has such issues with herself. But nothing besides her hightissues pointed in that direction at all, not that heavy at least... i mean, she is basically at a point where she asks herself "why do i even breathe? Am i allowed to consume air?" Thats just... way off. The lying part is another thing that doesnt fit her character. A little white lie is something else, but being fine with it to even lie to the MC about her problems is something completely off character for Josy, cause she was way more honest than Maya from the start. And now not anymore... that is totally strange and doesnt fit her character. Even the "vibrator" scene was something that bothered me... Josy had ZERO problems to be daring with the MC basically all the time... and all of a sudden not anymore? What? I really have my problems with how DPC wrote Josy in the last 3 episodes... its to sudden and makes no sense, not how it is shown now.