grarg
Member
- Dec 16, 2020
- 360
- 496
- 215
Ok. What exactly was not resolved?
I'm looking for a needle in a haystack with you. Becky annoys Josy and Maya twice in the same scenario in the library, and Maya gets a bit uncomfortable about it, while Josy has no problem in both examples. Once again proving that Josy's Ep11 "wah" moment comes out of nowhere.
What deeper issues? You mean when Josy off screen starts reading Satre and questions why she loves Maya and is even at school? That soap box that came out of nowhere?
...which is?
Then what exactly are we talking about?
If we see CHAPTERS upon CHAPTERS of the throuple having a good time, going through hardship, dealing with hardship, and then being positive...I mean, what are you talking about?
Again: what are you talking about?
It's like you have some insight into Josys' psyche. Like, was she tortured as a child? Then, she'd been repressing this trauma all her life? Suddenly, Episode 11 comes by, and you think it all makes sense?
What exact issues are you talking about, and where did they come from? A character can't just put their foot down and start spouting nonsense like "I was traumatised as a child" and expect an audience to buy it. But there isn't any trauam with Josy: she's totally fine! Just because you THINK there's something there without evidence doesn't mean it's there. Just because DPC decides to pull a 180 doesn't mean it makes sense.
Citation needed. Prove your statements.
Let's this this again:
1. Episode 9's Hallowe'en party was great for the two, outside of Oscar being mean to Josy. The Truth or Dare scene, who to choose, sex later, all positive.
This proves:
-Josy and Maya are having a good time with each other.
-They got together and did their hair, and Josy helped out with makeup and costume
-With alcohol combined
-With sex
-With throuple sex
-Alongside with Oscar making Josy feel bad. So there's good and bad. It's not all one big happy drunken sexy time. It's a party, things get messy and wild.
Kinda puts a big giant hole in your theory that there's something underneath the surface that's OH SO DANGEROUS and deadly to Josy's psyche when she's drunk, sexual, getting attacked, and being happy with the two people she loves.
2. Pete's phone call just made Josy embarrassed
Josy's getting embarrassed as MC talks to Pete. Yet she's still good ol Josy, not angry, violent, crazy, or having a breakdown, which would probably happen in a scenario like this if she has some childhood drama due to Pete, her mom, stepmom, or something she was repressing...similar to her showing the MC her blog -- but even that is just normal embarrassment. Josy's normally just a positive, confident and confident girl. Especially sexually.
In case you don't know, being sexually positive and confident in ones sexuality is a sign of maturity. Josy is perhaps one of the most mature ladies in the story...until her wah moment.
3. Episode 9/10's Tommy/Walk of Shame event, Josy's trying to resolve the conflict, and MC calls for the DIK code.
Another stressful moment, where the throuple is literally under conflict, along with family issues of Tommy, similar to the MC and his dad. Josy, Maya and MC get through it regardless, even with Josy trying to deflect Tommy.
So no, Josy, Maya, and the MC are having a pretty good relationship, despite all the slings and arrows. Which is expected. It's not perfect, but there's no trauma or existential angst or struggle causing Josy to QUESTION HER VERY EXISTENCE and LOVE FOR HER LOVER.
But WHERE exactly, in these, and other scenes, from Episode 4-11, does Josy have some hidden psychological issues, calling into question her inability to love Maya and the MC? Because I can point to about half a dozen sex scenes where she has no problems professing her VERY POSITIVE! Feelings to both.
What exactly are you saying then?
I've been anxiously awaiting for your response for over a month. I made a post about it in my signature. You've yet to respond. So please. Get to it.
ILLUMINATE US OH WISE ONE
...and that is what exactly?
First, how is something basic like "do you like me" immature and childish? Seems pretty simple and straightforward.
Secondly, Josy is even doing a constructive activity like blogging and photography during her supposed introspection moment. She isn't just scared in her room. So she's not some emotionally disgruntled exisntialist goth listening to alternative rock all day, or angry at some system of power, or scared or hates her parents or some authority figure. She's just Josy with all the old fixings...but now can't love Maya, doesn't know what she wants in life...and it makes no goddamned sense.
But nevermind that. I'm still waiting on 1) where this traume came from, 2) where it's manifested throughout the 9 or so other chapters us Plebs can't seem to find. Oh wise one!
