Yes I was on both paths and it was a hard choice between the two, but Bella is just... I guess I'll enjoy 3 chapters with her and then go back to replay the last 3 chapters with Jill and decide which is gonna stay as main walkthrough.Currently you're stuck to either Jill or Bella, but there are hints in season 3 (especially episode 11) that we might get to do more with both (probably at the same time) if you were on both of their paths pre-crossroads in episode 8.