I'm not asking for screenshots, that takes a while to do. But if you say he's dishonest you have to be thinking of some moment were he was, right? So you should at least tell me where to look. Because otherwise you're not stating an opinion, you're just making stuff up. I'm just asking you to back your claims.
You have several choices to be dishonest: Telling maya about going on a date with Josie (some girl back home at that point) being one of them.
There is also dishonesty by omission. At no point apart from Jill do you specifically say that you are seeing other girls. Or fucking around if that's your play through. That builds false expectations. Cus outside of Josie and Maya, you're not dating bella, or sage, or quinn, or any of the other HOTs. Big difference between whoring around and dating.
Now a lot of this is down to the fact that you do not have a choice to either say these things or not. Hence that is a problem within the confines of the story, no player agency. But that does not change the fact that the MC is not blameless in this. I'm really coming round to the theory it's more of a kick in his face, as it also shows how much of a schmuck he has been.
There is a double standard going on. Anyone arguing that anyone in the triangle is completely blameless is really only filtering what they want to see.
Also, interesting thing about facts, they eventually become untrue. Look up QI's half life of facts. What you want to be looking at is evidence.
