VN Ren'Py Being a DIK [v0.11.1] [DrPinkCake]

[suspiciousbarrel]

If you said it's bad writing I could agree with you, it makes no sense that Josy goes from being about to break up with Maya and move with the MC to friendzone the MC, among other things. But it's not a plot hole, a plot hole is something else.

I consider it a plot hole because MC unquestionably cheated on both of them and hid that but neither of them ever recognize that fact when they discover it. It would be bad writing if they were okay with it. They never even mention that MC has cheated on them. It's like this plot point has been lost, creating a plot hole.

 

[CheeseNinja009]

MC definitely overreacted with what happened, and for me he doesn't have all the right to get mad like that as he was also involved with the cheating thing. But what pisses me off is how Maya and Josy acted after that mess, they just chose to reconcile and make out in an "instant" even after the fact that they knew they cheated with the same guy. I just lost all my care for them, anyways I've got my Jill with me, I'm happier that way.

 

[Wizard_Shiryuu]

I consider it a plot hole because MC unquestionably cheated on both of them and hid that but neither of them ever recognize that fact when they discover it. It would be bad writing if they were okay with it. They never even mention that MC has cheated on them. It's like this plot point has been lost, creating a plot hole.

Yeah, that's not what a plot hole is. And no, the MC didn't cheat on anybody. You can't cheat if you're not in a relationship . Josy and Maya did cheat on each other and forgave each other too easily, that's something I have a problem with. But the MC didn't cheat, and you get the option to tell both J&M you're fooling around with other girls (or not). Where's the cheating there?

 

[suspiciousbarrel]

Yeah, that's not what a plot hole is. And no, the MC didn't cheat on anybody. You can't cheat if you're not in a relationship . Josy and Maya did cheat on each other and forgave each other too easily, that's something I have a problem with. But the MC didn't cheat, and you get the option to tell both J&M you're fooling around with other girls (or not). Where's the cheating there?

First, plot hole is literally any impossible or unlikely event or inconsistency with the plot, so yes it definitely is one. Secondly, it matters not at all that you have an option to tell them that "you're fooling around" because you have an option not to as I did and that changed fuck all in their reaction to what happened. Thirdly I understand that porn games have completely rotted the minds of people in here but if MC tries to pursue relationship with 2 girls and fucks one of them while having done a bunch of sexual things and coming close to having sex with the other one he indeed is cheating on both of them. You don't have to to get a government certified license that would recognize you as a couple before you can cheat on someone.

 

[SpikeZg]

MC has been a little whining bitch in this episode and Derek should have slapped the stupid out of him

 

[Deleted member 79621]

I just finished my recent run of BaDIK and I have been taking screenshots of a lot of things that I want to talk about in a long theory post that I will try to talk about multiple subjects at once. I will include the images with it so it's gonna be a big ass post and I'm not sure if I'm looking forward to writing it. I also have to decide to not be lazy enough to write it but I hope I'll get around to it at some point. This forum has been dry lately of theories and discussions regarding things in the game, so I want to hopefully reignite some people to get involved.

 

[Ryder-Wilson]

The MC is not engaged with one of the girls so he hasn't cheat. He can date others(on one of my playthrough i avoided the sex with Josy because the MC wanted something serious and was waiting for Josy to break up with her "boyfriend". If you play the "casanova" path he overacted and can admit it during a dialogue. This is called role-play). The cheaters are both Maya and Josy. The triangle it's temporary and you will lose both girls in the end or maybe get engaged with Josy. I don't think that this is a plot hole but yes need more develop and it's impossible to end like that(this game it's still in develop and is not finished). Both these girls are like lost sheep and can be corrupted. The MC is there for "save" both or one of the girls if he want.

 

[Wizard_Shiryuu]

First, plot hole is literally any impossible or unlikely event or inconsistency with the plot, so yes it definitely is one. Secondly, it matters not at all that you have an option to tell them that "you're fooling around" because you have an option not to as I did and that changed fuck all in their reaction to what happened. Thirdly I understand that porn games have completely rotted the minds of people in here but if MC tries to pursue relationship with 2 girls and fucks one of them while having done a bunch of sexual things and coming close to having sex with the other one he indeed is cheating on both of them. You don't have to to get a government certified license that would recognize you as a couple before you can cheat on someone.

I'll adress those by order.

No, a plot hole is a glaring contradiction of something previously stablished. Jill working in the Pink Rose could be a plot hole, because it contradicts everything preiously stablished for the character. Josy, Maya and the MC reacting the way they did doesn't contradict their personalities or anything. Bad writing? Maybe. But not a plot hole.

Telling them you're foolin around with other girls or not is irrelevant. Josy is on a relationship and Maya is only asking you to help her, neither of them demanded exclusivity from you. It's not cheating. Even Jill agrees with me.



And lastly, people in this thread are very sensible and discuss about pretty much anything peacefully. Saying that porn games corrupted our minds is disrespectful towards me and the others. You're entitled to your opinion, but you can express it without insulting others.

 

[Ryder-Wilson]

I'll adress those by order.

No, a plot hole is a glaring contradiction of something previously stablished. Jill working in the Pink Rose could be a plot hole, because it contradicts everything preiously stablished for the character. Josy, Maya and the MC reacting the way they did doesn't contradict their personalities or anything. Bad writing? Maybe. But not a plot hole.

Telling them you're foolin around with other girls or not is irrelevant. Josy is on a relationship and Maya is only asking you to help her, neither of them demanded exclusivity from you. It's not cheating. Even Jill agrees with me.

View attachment 526386

And lastly, people in this thread are very sensible and discuss about pretty much anything peacefully. Saying that porn games corrupted our minds is disrespectful towards me and the others.

Well, Jill is the perfect woman. When she said that, it didn't surprise me. Beautiful and with the best personality for my opinion. Anyway, both Maya and Josy are cheater(but with different reasons) but i don't think it's a plot hole like i said. Need more develop and people can't expect that every questions got answers in one season.

 

[Wizard_Shiryuu]

Well, Jill is the perfect woman. When she said that, it didn't surprise me. Beautiful and with the best personality for my opinion. Anyway, both Maya and Josy are cheater(but with different reasons) but i don't think it's a plot hole like i said. Need more develop and people can't expect that every questions got answers in one season.

It surprised me. I would have expected her to not like it. Even if it's not cheating she could be disappointed in the MC and could not want to date him anymore, I didn't expect her to have that point of view.

 

[GermanioBR]

someone knows where the temp files are located?

 

[android3231]

 

[Ryder-Wilson]

It surprised me. I would have expected her to not like it. Even if it's not cheating she could be disappointed in the MC and could not want to date him anymore, I didn't expect her to have that point of view.

That point of view is not something new even in real life. She is also very polite and mature and she already showed these traits of her.

 

[kaito_kitsudo]

i cant open the phone in 14th free roam when we have to visit jill, help plz !

 

[Monetauro]

I consider it a plot hole because MC unquestionably cheated on both of them...

Wizard_Summoner must work as a teacher or something, because this man is made of patience.

MC has been a little whining bitch in this episode and Derek should have slapped the stupid out of him

But he did, and as much as that was not the reason, I was very happy and relieved.

Spoiler

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

I just finished my recent run of BaDIK and I have been taking screenshots of a lot of things that I want to talk about in a long theory post that I will try to talk about multiple subjects at once. I will include the images with it so it's gonna be a big ass post and I'm not sure if I'm looking forward to writing it. I also have to decide to not be lazy enough to write it but I hope I'll get around to it at some point. This forum has been dry lately of theories and discussions regarding things in the game, so I want to hopefully reignite some people to get involved.

 

[Wizard_Shiryuu]

I just finished my recent run of BaDIK and I have been taking screenshots of a lot of things that I want to talk about in a long theory post that I will try to talk about multiple subjects at once. I will include the images with it so it's gonna be a big ass post and I'm not sure if I'm looking forward to writing it. I also have to decide to not be lazy enough to write it but I hope I'll get around to it at some point. This forum has been dry lately of theories and discussions regarding things in the game, so I want to hopefully reignite some people to get involved.

It's true that this episode didn't have much to theorize about. A tiny bit about Quinn's plan and that's pretty much it. The only theory of mine that I could "update" is the John Boy and Elena one. That's saying something . So sure, any fuel to discussion is great!

 

[SpikeZg]

i hope tomorrow we'll get some fresh news about ep5 with a new preview pic

 

[UnoriginalUserName]

It's true that this episode didn't have much to theorize about. A tiny bit about Quinn's plan and that's pretty much it. The only theory of mine that I could "update" is the John Boy and Elena one. That's saying something . So sure, any fuel to discussion is great!

Are you kidding?

Where was Sage and who was she meeting? Is she involved in Quinn's plans or is this something separate?
Did Derek really fuck a feminist outdoors? REALLY?
What's going to happen since the MC and Derek didn't egg the preps?
Will Karen Rebecca Johnson, 19 years and 2 months old and with plans to become a librarian, ever become a possible love interest or get over her fear of cows?
Will Josy become a stripper?
Will Jill and Josy actually become friends?
Will Bella's plants ever get enough water?
Is Heather becoming interested in the MC?
Are Arieth's crabs spreading out of control?
Is Tybalt Jade's son?
What are Quinn's plans and what kind of trouble is she having with them that requires a change?
Are we finally done with the dumpster fire that is Maya and Josy?
Can we actually ignore Maya and Josy from here on out?

And, most importantly, when will Quinn realize her love for the MC and become a main girl we can spend more time with?

 

[Wizard_Shiryuu]

Are you kidding?

Where was Sage and who was she meeting? Is she involved in Quinn's plans or is this something separate?
Did Derek really fuck a feminist outdoors? REALLY?
What's going to happen since the MC and Derek didn't egg the preps?
Will Karen Rebecca Johnson, 19 years and 2 months old and with plans to become a librarian, ever become a possible love interest or get over her fear of cows?
Will Josy become a stripper?
Will Jill and Josy actually become friends?
Will Bella's plants ever get enough water?
Is Heather becoming interested in the MC?
Are Arieth's crabs spreading out of control?
Is Tybalt Jade's son?
What are Quinn's plans and what kind of trouble is she having with them that requires a change?
Are we finally done with the dumpster fire that is Maya and Josy?
Can we actually ignore Maya and Josy from here on out?

And, most importantly, when will Quinn realize her love for the MC and become a main girl we can spend more time with?

Well, yeah. There's that bit about Sage and Quinn's plan. The others are pretty minor or are there from previous episodes already. The one about KRJ had he laughing, though .

 

[SpikeZg]

Pink - 3,699 patrons